Community Hospitals
e-Newsletter
Intelligence Unit Special Reports Special Events Subscribe Sponsored Departments Follow Us

Twitter Facebook LinkedIn RSS

McAllen, Texas Docs Defend Region's Healthcare Spending

Cheryl Clark, for HealthLeaders Media, June 24, 2009

The border town of McAllen, Texas wasn't on the tip of anybody's tongue before this month. But a few weeks ago, an article in The New Yorker offered it up as exhibit A of all that is wrong with the country's healthcare system, the ground zero of medicine run amok.

In recent weeks, the president himself reportedly carried the magazine into conference rooms announcing that the article, which was called "The Cost Conundrum", was mandatory reading for anyone who was serious about joining the health reform conversation.

But yesterday, the doctors of McAllen began to fight back. In a news conference in Washington, D.C. directed at President Barack Obama and Congress, they said The New Yorker and the article's author, Atul Gawande, MD, got it all wrong.

Gawande, who visited McAllen some months ago, attributed his statistics on McAllen to the Dartmouth Atlas of Healthcare's compendium of Medicare spending costs throughout the country. It showed, he wrote, that McAllen has the second highest per capita spending of Medicare dollars in the nation, next to Miami where the costs of practicing are much greater. In McAllen, the $15,000 annual spending on medical expenses is twice that of the national average, Gawande said.

A surgeon at Harvard Medical School's Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston, Gawande blamed McAllen's expensive tab on an assortment of McAllen's physician entrepreneurs who have set up large medical practices that perform a lot of imaging and other tests, and formed hospital companies that keep patients longer than average. In effect, Gawande accused McAllen's medical system of over-utilizing and overcharging the federal government.

But yesterday, at the start of a Border Health Caucus in Washington, officials from the Texas Medical Association and the Hidalgo-Starr County Medical Society, explained that is hardly the case.

And they asked that the president come to McAllen to see for himself.

McAllen is different than any other place in the U.S. It provides healthcare to an extremely needy and poor population, they said, and is just more expensive because the healthcare needs are so great.

In effect, they said, Gawande used statistics that were not risk-adjusted for the severity of health problems in McAllen.

For starters, said society president James Stewart, MD, a McAllen internist, Hidalgo County has the lowest average income of any county in the nation, which means it is the poorest. Because of that, as well as its proximity to the border, it is beset with more than its share of health challenges. It has high numbers of uninsured, high numbers of undocumented immigrants, and a high percentages of people who, when they are diagnosed with an illness, their providers learn they have never seen a physician.

Comments are moderated. Please be patient.

2 comments on "McAllen, Texas Docs Defend Region's Healthcare Spending"


Sony (10/7/2012 at 9:00 AM)
I Know from first hand experience that Atul Gawade is absolutely right. I recently had an abscess and went to a doctor for that. I was immediately send to doctors hospital at renaissance, and instead of a simple I& D , had to spent 4 days(!) in the hospital. I was simply shuttled from one doctor to other ( while in the hospital I was seen by another doctor that the original doctor has recommended, had I&dperformed by a surgeon from another group (McAllen physicians) and for a simple work excuse ( the doctor who 'saw' me at the hospital 'ld have given it to me) was referred back to the original doctor ( of course! I need to make an appointment for that too!!) and was told to make an appointment in a week with another surgeon ( not the surgeon who performed the actual procedure)!! . The absolute apathy they show to the patient is very very evident and they just treat people like an ATM machine. If I ever had to see a doctor or needs to be admitted in a hospital, it is never going to be in Rio grande valley-So help me God.

William Pastor (12/18/2010 at 6:54 PM)
Atul Gawande preempted this argument in his article, correctly pointing out that El Paso county is demographically similar to Hidalgo county (where McAllen is) and has per capita Medicare expenditures literally half those of Hidalgo. There are lots of poor places in America and lots of sick people, Hidalgo County just has a bad medical culture. And it's no surprise that the doctors there would rather deny the existence of the problem than improve the situation.