Layoffs an Effective Strategy for Economic Crisis, But Beware the Downstream Costs
The last two years of deep recession have forced many executives in the healthcare sector to take drastic steps to curb costs. Even though healthcare is one of the few sectors in the overall economy to see job growth, hospitals have not been immune to layoffs and other staff reductions.
While the job cuts may have an immediate effect on cost containment, other downstream costs should be considered.
The new HealthLeaders Media Industry Survey 2010 found that 38% of hospital CEOs and 46% of CFOs found layoffs and staff reductions to be an effective strategy when dealing with an economic crisis, while 37% and 35% of CEOs and CFOs, respectively, remained neutral about the idea. Only 25% of CEOs and 19% of CFOs found layoffs to be ineffective. [See Question 13.]
When C-suite denizens are asked in the survey to gauge the impact of healthcare trends on their hospitals in the next three years, their responses provide an interesting contrast. For example, 51% of CEOs say the nursing shortage will negatively impact their operations, and 53% say organized labor will negatively impact their organizations. [See Question 6.]
So, on the one hand, 75% or more of senior hospital executives either support or are neutral on the idea that layoffs are effective, while half of those same executives say they're apprehensive about workforce shortages and unions.
Here's the problem: Cutting staff–regardless of the motive–will save money short term, but it also will exacerbate future workforce shortages when it's time to start hiring again, and push remaining employees–fearful of job security–into the welcoming arms of organized labor.
Is there disconnect here?
Not entirely, but there is some static on the line.
To be fair, these executives in the survey aren't necessarily saying they're in favor of layoffs. They're saying that layoffs are an effective short-term strategy to deal with the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression. Many healthcare executives probably view layoffs as a regrettable last resort.
"I can't envision a scenario where a staff reduction is really an effective long-term strategy. It really falls much more closely along the lines of a short-term tactical response to a financial situation," says Bernie Becker, vice president/CHRO at Stormont-Vail HealthCare in Topeka, KS. "If you look at it strategically, unless you are eliminating programs and services and the people that are needed to deliver those programs and services, when business rebounds you are going to have to staff back up.
Most of the time, you are going to have higher labor costs than if you had left those people in place. It's always more expensive to hire people than it is to keep them." Chris Roederer, vice president of HR at Tampa General Hospital, concedes that layoffs are effective at containing costs. However, he says, hospitals that conduct layoffs risk losing long-term credibility with remaining employees.
"Many organizations that conduct layoffs feel the pain for years to come. Employees do not forget," he says. "With proper planning, organizations would be better served by meeting staffing reductions via attrition. That avoids the negative employee relations impact, potential negative impact on long-term recruitment, and severance and unemployment expense."
Lose employees' confidence and you also lose critical allies in the fight to identify and contain costs. "If employees trust and respect leadership, they will typically understand and even assist leadership in eliminating other expenses to avoid layoffs such as minimizing overtime, special pay practices, or modified shifts," Roederer says.
- CMS to Speak with ICD-10 Backers Tuesday
- Feds Stonewall ICD-10 Summit
- Managed Care Contract Negotiations Morph Under PPACA
- Hospital Groups Back NQF Report on Patient Sociodemographics
- Governor Details Healthcare Payment Reform Path in Arkansas
- Cyberattack Drill Exposes Healthcare's Vulnerabilities
- Boston Marathon Bombing Yields Lessons for Hospitals
- Physician Payment Data is Where the Action Is
- NY Abolishes Written Practice Agreement for NPs
- MetroHealth Revs Its Population Health Engine