Will Primary Care Be Re-Empowered by an Ailing Economy?
For some time, we have speculated that America's health system is sliding towards a financial crisis that could spill over into the general economy and bring it down.
The logic goes like this: explosive growth in the cost of healthcare is pricing rank-and-file Americans out of the coverage market and reducing the system's (inflation-adjusted) available revenues. All the while, service demands have continued to increase, creating a mounting resource-demand mismatch.
We can see this already on the system's edges, in the crises or shutdowns at the nation?s safety net health systems—Martin Luther King in Los Angeles, Women's Hospital in Philadelphia, Grady Hospital in Atlanta—where demands for care simply outstripped the resources required to provide it. Because healthcare is one-seventh of the economy and one-eleventh of its jobs, a meltdown that starts at healthcare's edges and then spreads throughout the industry might cascade to all other sectors as well, wreaking havoc throughout the economy.
Now we believe it could happen the other way around, with the collapse of financial institutions sinking healthcare markets. Consider what might happen, for example, if the many health systems whose margins have been kept afloat through investment income, suddenly lost that revenue stream. The ability to provide care, or to purchase goods and services from others in the health industry, would be dramatically compromised.
Market-based, not policy-based reforms
As the largest part of the economy, America's health system will be sorely tested by the financial markets' turmoil. The challenges posed by diminished resources and the tightening of credit will intensify the pressure on healthcare professionals and organizations that have long resisted major structural changes—like the re-empowerment of primary care, pricing and performance transparency, and payments linked to results—that can finally check rampant cost growth and re-establish stability and sustainability to the industry. If they suddenly share in our pain, they're more likely to be receptive.
Despite the current wisdom, the major levers for reform aren't likely to come from the federal government. In 2007, members of Congress accepted $445 million from the healthcare industry, about 16% of all the lobbying contributions accepted from special interests in exchange for influence over policy. They're hardly likely to disappoint their benefactors by passing laws that would drive out the significant healthcare waste that is an important portion of revenues and margin.
And even if they were interested in addressing the problem, and even if healthcare hadn't fallen off the political radar screen compared to the economy, gas prices, food prices, the current economic turmoil and mounting budget deficits would trump Congress' ability to focus dollars on fixing healthcare.
No, it won't be big government, but big business that drives change. Business is finally apoplectic about healthcare's excesses—the cost, the questionable quality, the lack of demonstrable value, and the employee dissatisfaction—and fed up with its excuses. They want results right now. They don't know why health plans—supposedly their surrogates to insure good care at reasonable cost—and the health industry as a whole aren't cooperating.
Businesses' own growth and economic health depends on its ability to compete globally. Now, in a new push, business leaders appear to be coming together and mobilizing decisively to change the ways the system. They are mad as hell, and they're tired of haggling. They're not going to take it any more, and they're giving notice of their intentions. They are in a mood to demand cooperation, and if it is not there, to seek their own solutions.
Two facets of a primary care initiative by business
Given this backdrop of economic turmoil, increasing pressure on the industry, and business' dissatisfaction with healthcare, let's examine two major events—worksite clinics and primary care re-empowerment—that underscore business' determination to transform the system, and in the process, cut costs, insure quality, and satisfy their employees. Both are focused on "the medical home," though the worksite clinic model is, at this point, the most fully realized by far.
The uptake of worksite clinics by mid-sized and large corporations is so rapid that it is hard to understand it in any terms but transformative. Walgreens estimates that America has about 7,600 corporate campuses with 1,000 or more employees (that would generally mean about 2,200 or more lives). About half of all Fortune firms are expected to have clinics by 2010. Because a properly configured clinic is scalable and provides a platform for very proactive management of care both inside the clinic and downstream, on the network, the trend is spreading like wildfire to smaller firms with as few as 250 employees. They're also being bundled with high deductible plans and becoming available to coalitions of smaller employers as well.
Large clinic firms, like Walgreens' subsidiary Take Care, and smaller ones like Orlando-based WeCare TLC and Atlanta-based Worksite Rx, are actively catering to the rush of employers who see this model as a way to dramatically improve care while reducing cost.
"Think of an employer sitting at the table with his healthcare relationships: brokers, health plans, doctors, hospitals, drug and device companies. Everyone but him wants it to cost more, and they are all in direct control of cost creation. So our model is different. We have two goals: Providing better care for the patient, and being a fiduciary for the purchaser. Everything else is secondary." That's a comment by Lynn Jennings, board chair of WeCare TLC, and it typifies an orientation that caters to this new corporate activism on healthcare.
Worksite clinics offer fully integrated health management platforms, separate from and in front of the health plans. Participation is voluntary, but patients who use the clinic don't need to access the health plan until they leave the clinic. In other words, the model goes around the health plan to achieve savings, quality improvement, and employee satisfaction.
The clinics build in significant incentives for both patients and doctors. Employees using the clinics may get free visits, free drugs and labs. Access to the clinics is convenient, fast, private, and secure. Time spent in the clinic often doesn't count as paid time off.
- CEO Exchange: Preparing for Population Health
- Advocate, NorthShore Deal Would Create 16-Hospital System
- EHR Systems 'Immature, Costly,' AMA Says
- Better HCAHPS Scores Protect Revenue
- Narrow Networks Cut Costs, Not Quality, Economists Say
- 3 Strategies for Retaining Millennial Employees
- 'Early Offer' Malpractice Programs May Spur Reform
- Power of price: In South FL and the nation, healthcare costs often are shrouded in secrecy
- Hospital mergers may lead to higher prices