Technology
e-Newsletter
Intelligence Unit Special Reports Special Events Subscribe Sponsored Departments Follow Us

Twitter Facebook LinkedIn RSS

Dartmouth Revises Medicare Spending Variation Report

Cheryl Clark, for HealthLeaders Media, June 24, 2011

Dartmouth Atlas researchers have taken to heart last year's heated criticism that they hadn't adjusted for variations in regional cost of living differences when they published statistical maps showing wide regional variations in Medicare per capita spending. This week, statisticians with the group released a new set of tables that do just that.

Most of the 306 geographic hospital referral regions moved a few points up or down, but most noteworthy were downward shifts in spending for New York City and San Francisco, Dartmouth statistician Jonathan Skinner said in a telephone interview.

"We published these measures for years where we didn't adjust for the fact that Medicare pays more in San Francisco, Chicago and New York than in other places," Skinner said. "And over time, people said, 'Oh, our city costs (Medicare) a lot more because everything costs more in our city.'

"So we decided to redo the whole thing where we did it both ways – price adjusted and unadjusted, and with a larger Medicare sample size, 20% (of Medicare fee for service beneficiaries) instead of 5%," he said. "We felt it was important for researchers and policymakers to have this data available in case they want to know how much cheaper is San Francisco really."

The Dartmouth Atlas had been a relatively obscure set of maps showing the amounts providers in various regions of the country submitted in healthcare claims for Medicare beneficiaries. But during the health reform debate, the maps came alive, showing how providers in some regions of the country were providing patients with a lot more expensive care, but with apparent negligible benefit to their survival.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4

Comments are moderated. Please be patient.

1 comments on "Dartmouth Revises Medicare Spending Variation Report"


Rob Forster MD (6/28/2011 at 12:12 PM)
Having been a healthcare plan executive in Florida for near 10 years gave me time to study Miami. Those who live there >65 are healthier than average and both unit cost and utilization of services are higher than average No. Florida seniors. Unit cost are stratospheric[INVALID]Historical high FFS Medicare drove the current base for payment and reform never occured. In the private sector $5000-7,000/day in the University of Miami is not unusual in their contracts for acute medical beds. That is 3-5X the national norm. Seniors who are visiting So. Florida and fall ill are typically very sick and heavy over utilization of services is the standard.