Leadership
e-Newsletter
Intelligence Unit Special Reports Special Events Subscribe Sponsored Departments Follow Us

Twitter Facebook LinkedIn RSS

IPAB Wields Chainsaw for Want of a Scalpel

Philip Betbeze, for HealthLeaders Media, September 23, 2011

Whether you attribute the quote to Otto von Bismarck or Gustave Flaubert, many would agree with the  sentiment that watching democracy in action is like watching sausage being made. The punchline is that while you may or may not like the result, the process will make you sick.

In that case, call the Independent Payment Advisory Board one of the sausages that came out of the process of creating the Patient Protection and Affordable Healthcare Act.

In case you forgot, the 15-member board will be comprised of doctors, nurses, medical experts, and consumers who recommend ways to reduce healthcare spending. They are allowed to analyze the drivers of Medicare cost growth and recommend policies to control Medicare costs if spending exceeds a targeted growth rate of 1% more than gross domestic product growth.

They haven't yet been appointed, and their first report to Congress isn't due until July 2014, but debates over their mandate are generating real fear—especially in the physician specialty arena.

Board members will be appointed by the president and must be confirmed by the Senate. The difference between this board and the other major board that recommends changes in Medicare policy, the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission, is that IPAB actually has the power to implement the changes it wants, with key — and very limiting — restrictions.

In fact, Congress must vote to block any of the Board's recommendations or they will automatically become policy.

1 | 2 | 3

Comments are moderated. Please be patient.

1 comments on "IPAB Wields Chainsaw for Want of a Scalpel"


Patrick Plemmons (9/23/2011 at 1:42 PM)
Anyone who wishes for a "benevolent dictator" in healthcare is foolish in the extreme. Do you really want a group of politicized, unelected bureaucrats controlling personal medical care in this country? Have we devalued personal freedom so much that we are willing to cede control of our own health to big government? Government control of healthcare is already onerous [INVALID] to wish for more is inexplicable. The Stockholm Syndrome comes to mind.