ACA's Fate Rests with Court
A roller coaster ride of federal court decisions
PPACA began winding through the court system almost immediately after it was passed in March 2010. The first sign of trouble came in August 2010 when a district court in the Eastern District of Virginia declined federal government's motion to dismiss. That set the ACA on a roller coaster ride of federal court decisions with some supporting the individual mandate and others ruling it unconstitutional. In November 2011 the Supreme Court agreed to review the case.
In eight hours of oral arguments over three days five lawyers debated four key issues: jurisdiction, the individual mandate, "severability" (whether the individual mandate severable from PPACA), and the expansion of Medicaid eligibility.
Every question, nuance, and inflection of the justices during oral arguments has been parsed by observers and pundits in an effort to discern how the court might ultimately rule. While that's all very interesting, attorney Thomas Barker says the oral arguments will have little effect on the ultimate outcome. "If their minds aren't already made up then they get made up based on the briefs filed by the parties and maybe the amicus briefs but not what happens at oral arguments."
Barker, who specializes in healthcare and is partner in the Washington, DC office of Foley Hoag, says he began the week thinking that the individual mandate would be upheld, but admits that he's not as sure now.
"I had the sense that the court would be reluctant to choose this case as the limit for how far the commerce clause power can go. I was skeptical that would happen, but Justice Kennedy seemed to put that in play."
- Surgical Checklists Unused in 10% of Hospitals, CMS Data Shows
- Doctors Feel Pressure to Accept Risk-based Reimbursement
- Roundtable: To Arrest HAIs, Culture Trumps Campaigns
- Wanted: Nurse PhDs
- 4 Tectonic Shifts Shaking Up Healthcare
- Slideshow: Healthcare Leaders Name IT Spending Priorities
- A Fresh Look at End-of-Life Care
- 3 in 4 Patients Want E-mail Consultations
- New Orleans East Hospital opens quietly, still seeking accreditation
- CVS Ramps Up Retail Clinics with Provider Affiliations