UnitedHealth Group False Claims Suit Back on Track
The district court had held that compliance with the AKS was not a condition for payment from the government under the federal health insurance program and that Wilkins and Willis didn’t have a claim for relief under the False Claims Act.
According to the facts and procedural history included in the ruling, Wilkins and Willis began working with UnitedHealth Group and AmeriChoice in 2007, Willis as a general manager for Medicare/Medicaid marketing and sales and Wilkins as a sales representative. In 2008, UnitedHealth terminated Wilkins' employment and demoted and then terminated Willis, allegedly for their complaints about what they perceived as illegal practices.
Among the allegations in the suit, which was filed in 2008, is that AmeriChoice's sales representatives paid $27,000 to Reliance Medical Group to switch certain eligible beneficiaries to its Medicare and Medicaid plans and that United Health's sales representatives offered payments to physicians in exchange for the physicians providing the names of potential new enrollees eligible for Medicare and Medicaid.
In remanding the anti-kickback portion of the suit the Third Circuit Court of Appeals noted “compliance with the AKS is clearly a condition of payment under Parts C and D of Medicare and appellees (UHG and AmeriChoice-New Jersey) do not refer us to any judicial precedent holding otherwise.” The ruling also stated that Walkins and Willis “ by alleging that appellees violated the AKS while submitting claims for payment to a federal health insurance program, have stated a plausible claim for relief under the FCA.”
UnitedHealth Group has not issued a statement on the case.
Margaret Dick Tocknell is a reporter/editor with HealthLeaders Media.
- CMS Offers Some ACOs $114M for 'Upfront' Costs
- WellPoint Dominates Nearly Half of Markets, AMA Says
- Ebola: Second TX Nurse Diagnosed After Improper Protective Gear Application
- 16 Medicare Advantage Plans Earn 5-Star Ratings
- Ebola: A Call for Designated Hospitals
- Providers Ask HHS to Address EHR Interoperability Barriers
- CDC admits to mistakes in Ebola protocol
- 76% of Nurses Say No Ebola Policy Communicated by Hospitals
- CMS' new investment model will help ACOs with health IT
- Obama Names 'Ebola Czar'