Peer Review of Surgeons' Skills Carries 'Threatening Undertones'
HLM: Has any other research project rated surgeons' skill and then paired it with patient outcomes like yours?
JB: To my knowledge, no. There's a large body of attempts to rate surgical residents' skill, but I'm not aware of any systematic attempt to peer-rate the technical skill of mature practicing surgeons, much less link those ratings to objective measures of surgeons' outcomes.
HLM: Might this prompt surgeons to be defensive and to object to such a process?
JB: Yes, there certainly is a threatening undertone to this.
HLM: The obvious question is whether this technique might be used to score surgical skill for procedures other than gastric bypass. Is it ready for prime time?
JB: There's no doubt in my mind we have a reproducible, reliable, and highly informative way of judging the comparative quality of practicing bariatric surgeons…although it will have to be confirmed by others.
And I believe it would likely extrapolate to other procedures such as robotic radical prostatectomy and robotic hysterectomy. And eventually, not just complex videoscopic surgery but other types of complex, complicated, surgery where how well the procedure is done bears on the outcome: Neurosurgery, spine, cardiac, vascular surgery and major orthopedics. I think scientific research will bear out this approach for a broad swath of surgeries.
HLM: What should you do with the poor performers? Now you'll have knowledge those folks aren't up to par, and you've now actually linked this to patient harm in higher complication rates. That's real.
JB: You have to ask who is the "you" in that sentence. Is it hospitals credentialing their own surgeons? The American Board of Surgery charged with certification of those surgeons? Regardless who the decision maker is, it's important to recognize there's a bell-shaped distribution. There will always be variation.
- Surgical Checklists Unused in 10% of Hospitals, CMS Data Shows
- Doctors Feel Pressure to Accept Risk-based Reimbursement
- Roundtable: To Arrest HAIs, Culture Trumps Campaigns
- Wanted: Nurse PhDs
- 4 Tectonic Shifts Shaking Up Healthcare
- Slideshow: Healthcare Leaders Name IT Spending Priorities
- A Fresh Look at End-of-Life Care
- 3 in 4 Patients Want E-mail Consultations
- New Orleans East Hospital opens quietly, still seeking accreditation
- CVS Ramps Up Retail Clinics with Provider Affiliations