Bundled Payments Come to Cancer Care
Success key No. 1: Evaluating drug costs
When a new breast cancer drug, pertuzumab, was approved by the FDA, physicians in UnitedHealthcare's bundling program added the medicine to their regimens based on promising results from clinical trails; the cost for the new regimen was approximately $180,000 for a course of therapy covering an 18-month period for each patient. The medication was, indeed, costly, but the physicians agreed it would set the stage for better outcomes. In addition, UnitedHealthcare pays for the cost of the drug, so physicians are not at risk for the expense. However, physicians do not make more money for using the more expensive medication, as they would in a fee-for-service payment model.
UnitedHealthcare calculated the drug margin for each selected regimen by subtracting the average sales price—the price determined by Medicare—from the group's usual reimbursement for the drug using the existing fee schedule. To determine the episode payment, UnitedHealthcare asked physician groups to identify the chemotherapy program that it thought would be best practice for the oncology programs, Newcomer says. The discussions were not always smooth. Not every member of the group used the same regimen, and they had to come to a consensus for the program."
When new evidence requires changing an episode's chemotherapy to a more expensive drug, the drug cost is reimbursed by UnitedHealthcare to the physician and the episode payment is not increased. "They don't get paid any more money now that they are using the drug," Newcomer says. "In the old system, the physicians would have made a lot more money, but that doesn't happen in this program. Everyone knows the drug profit model is going away and this model offers a unique way to increase physician payments."
The five medical groups involved in the UnitedHealthcare program used docetaxel and cyclophosphamide chemotherapy for early-stage breast cancer, yet costs of treatment varied by 100% among the groups, Newcomer says. The cost for drugs in the regimen would range from $9,000 to $22,000, he adds.
When new evidence requires changing an episode's chemotherapy regimen to a more expensive drug, the physician's episode payment is not increased.
Coordination and quality of care are just as important to evaluate as the drug costs, Newcomer says. Over the past several years, physicians and UnitedHealthcare's oncology group discussed how to assess the value for each scenario using more than 60 measures, such as survival, complication rates, and total cost.
The current bundling system differs drastically from what Newcomer described as the "buy-and-bill" scenario, in which oncologists earned the difference between what they paid for chemotherapy drugs and the amount they billed insurers.
Before the bundling program was implemented, there was discouragement "of lower-cost generic medications, even if the clinical results are similar," Newcomer says. "All of us are struggling to change behaviors to get better outcomes."
Success key No. 2: Physician involvement
A key for success in the episode of care model relies on physician involvement and providing quality care. Everyone agrees this one will be tricky.
Medical groups may change their regimens at any time, but the episode payment will not be adjusted for new drug selections. Each physician identifies eligible patients during the initial consultation, and his or her office registers the patient with UnitedHealthcare under its program.
"We're taking on some of the ownership of the cost of care for those patients," says Gould of the Northwest Georgia Oncology Centers. "We're transitioning from fee-for-service to one in which we are paid for global care of the patient," Gould adds. The Northwest Georgia Oncology Center is part of the UnitedHealthcare episode of care pilot project.
- Readmissions: No Quick Fix to Costly Hospital Challenge
- Ebola: Health Officials Try to Quell Front Line Fears
- How Telehealth Pays Off for Providers, Patients
- Reducing Readmissions Starts with Better Collaboration
- Defensive Medicine Still Prevalent Despite Tort Reform
- 'Overtreatment' Debate Circles Back to Lung Cancer Screening
- Partners HealthCare M&A Deal Under Scrutiny
- How Educated Nurses Save Money
- Ebola: A New Normal in Dallas
- House Calls Key to Pioneer ACO Success