HL20: Clayton Christensen—The Innovator's Frustration
The national healthcare debate is anything but a model, he says. "I'm frustrated … it's the politicians—it's not that they are inert or that they don't want to do it, but they don't have time to sit down and wrap their arms around the problem or the solution, and their mindset is so fleeting that they want a simple answer." Debate has not yielded to deliberation, in Christensen's view. "Everybody convenes in Washington with self-serving data and self-serving arguments. It's kind of like the people in Washington are sitting around the base of the Tower of Babel, and they can't talk to each other, let alone come up with any answers," he says.
A big part of the political babble, he says, is the false choice between single-payer and multi-payer healthcare systems. "It turns out, as we've studied it subsequent to the writing of [The Innovator's Prescription], that categorizing the world as private multi-payer vs. government single-payer systems is the wrong categorization scheme. At their core, the publicly paid systems in Canada and the Netherlands and Germany are organized very much like most of America, in that the providers are in silos and their inability to stake a systemic view is just the same as in America."
But the integrated health systems that do exist in America "are organized in the same way that Sweden and Finland are organized. Those nations in Europe are way out ahead of those who are organized by silos, in terms of the efficacy and the cost of healthcare, in the same way that the systemic companies in America are way ahead."
To Christensen, who bases his books on research and who speaks in measured, carefully chosen sentences, proper terminology is the key to reforming healthcare. "What I had not realized is how critical a common language and a common way to frame the problem is in trying to make any significant progress in solving the healthcare problems," he says. "It's just really important that we frame the categorization in the right way. When you do that, it becomes clear that the systemic view is critical at this point. I understand that problem more than I did before."
This article appears in the December 2011 issue of HealthLeaders magazine.
Edward Prewitt is the Editorial Director of HealthLeaders Media.
- Sharp HealthCare Leaves Pioneer ACO Program
- Acute Kidney Injury Gets New Focus
- CNO Leads $1M Charge for New Scrubs, Uniforms
- Interventional Radiology No Longer a Sub-Specialty
- NFP Hospitals' Revenue Growth at 'All-Time Low'
- Half of All Primary Care, Internal Medicine Jobs Unfilled in 2013
- MA an Insurance Proving Ground for Providers
- PCI: Concerns Mount About Appropriateness
- Targeting Self-Insured Populations
- mHealth Tackles Readmissions