Peer Review of Surgeons' Skills Carries 'Threatening Undertones'
The challenge is where to draw that dotted line. What types of surgeons need to be targeted for remediation or redirection? The bottom 1%, 10%, or the bottom quarter? I expect there will be a lot of difficult discussions.
HLM: Yes, because you now have evidence of harm that you didn't have before. Surgeons submitted what they thought was their best work.
JB: That's a really important point, and I hadn't thought of it that way. The American Board of Surgery fails about 10% to 15% of surgeons every year, and they have to retake the test, and maybe go through other steps.
But you're right, the difference between those tests and what we're talking about here is, nobody has empirically linked how well you do on those tests to patients' risk of dying or other types of bad outcomes as we have with this study.
The stakes are much higher. That's why there's a threatening undercurrent to these findings as they get extrapolated to other specialties.
HLM: If I were a patient who had had surgery by a surgeon judged to have lower level of technical surgical skill, I would want to know. Did you tell the patients whose videos were used in this study?
JB: The study was monitored by the University of Michigan Institutional Review Board, and these surgeons submitted videos that were completely stripped of patient-identifying information. So we don't know which patients were attached to those videos. And furthermore, there was a blood oath of confidentiality, so even I don't know the identify of the surgeon who was the 2.6 or who was the 4.8. [Scores ranged from 1.0 – 5.0]
- Ebola: Health Officials Try to Quell Front Line Fears
- Reducing Readmissions Starts with Better Collaboration
- Ebola: A New Normal in Dallas
- Partners HealthCare M&A Deal Under Scrutiny
- Readmissions: No Quick Fix to Costly Hospital Challenge
- How Educated Nurses Save Money
- 'Overtreatment' Debate Circles Back to Lung Cancer Screening
- Health Literacy Month Gets a Boost from Payers
- How Top-Ranked MA Plans Earn Their Stars
- Defensive Medicine Still Prevalent Despite Tort Reform