1 in 5 ICU Patients Get 'Futile' Care
Wenger says it's unclear whether the finding can be extrapolated to other academic medical centers, or non-teaching community hospitals, whether profit or non-profit.
On one hand, a hospital system like UCLA's "is where a patient comes to get saved when they're about to die, a hospital that does organ transplants, and it may very well be that those same factors contribute to continuing to try hard even after you feel the treatments aren't useful."
In an accompanying invited commentary, Robert Truog, MD and Douglas B. White, MD, of Harvard Medical School's Department of Global Health and Social Medicine, were critical of the UCLA report.
First, they wrote that the assessments were made by "a single physician making a single assessment about futility," with no information on whether other doctors or members of the care team, including family, shared their views that care was futile.
Second, much of the $2.6 million cost represents fixed costs of running an ICU, "that cannot be eliminated unless critical care beds are closed," so the cost estimates "are almost certainly less."
Additionally, they wrote, "there is ongoing debate about the boundaries of acceptable practice near the end of life. Short of brain death, there are no criteria or rules to which clinicians can appeal to justify decisions to refuse life support, at least when those treatments hold even a small chance of achieving the patient's goals."
Cheryl Clark is senior quality editor and California correspondent for HealthLeaders Media. She is a member of the Association of Health Care Journalists.
- 'Kafkaesque' Value System Unfairly Penalizes Doctor Pay
- Proton Beam Therapy Poised for Growth in US
- mHealth Tackles Readmissions
- CNO Leads $1M Charge for New Scrubs, Uniforms
- Some Cancer Hospitals' Quality Data Will Soon Be Public
- 4 Crucial Tactics for Reining in Healthcare Cost
- How Digital Strategy Shapes Patient Engagement at Boston Children's Hospital
- How, and Why, to Recruit Male Nurses
- Half of All Primary Care, Internal Medicine Jobs Unfilled in 2013
- Docs Fret as HHS Addresses Malpractice Reporting 'Loopholes'