Urologists 'Outraged' Over PSA Test Challenge
Siegel says he is concerned about "the greatest damage" the report will have on prostate screenings for African-American men, who are disproportionately affected by prostate cancer.
"I have been a urologist for almost 30 years. When I started training, 40% of African-American men at that time presented with metastatic disease. Now that number is miniscule," Siegel says. "Tell me how that happens without early screening? How do death rates go down from 48,000 when I trained to 28,000 now? How do you explain that without screening? You can't! It's impossible!"
Even though the test is being discouraged by the task force, Siegel says he believes many men and their physicians will want to keep the option on the table.
"If I am with a patient, I'm going to tell them 'we have a blood test to help diagnose prostate cancer. Yes, there are false positives. But if you have prostate cancer, do you want to know or do you want to play Russian roulette?'" he says. "Of course, I wouldn't say it like that. But that is the question. Who's going to say no?"
John Commins is a senior editor with HealthLeaders Media.
- ICD-10: Minimizing the Financial Hit
- Hospital Compare Adds Infection, Stroke, Readmissions Data
- 3 Favorite Nursing Trends of 2013
- How One Provider is Saving Millions on Imaging Equipment
- HIT in 2014: Portal Perils and Half-Built Houses
- SLIDESHOW: HL20 — 20 People Who Are Making a Difference in Healthcare - 2013
- State Health Disparities Trace Medicaid Expansion
- Q&A: Banner CEO on 'Getting the Cost Out'
- Healthcare Unions Eye Gains in 2014
- Intelligence Report: Cost-Containment Expertise