Skip to main content

Medicare Advantage Premiums Fall 33% in Q1

Analysis  |  By Jack O'Brien  
   May 30, 2019

When zero-dollar premium plans were removed, costs still dropped by 13%, according to a survey from eHealth.

Average Medicare Advantage (MA) premiums dropped by more than 30% in Q1 2019, according to data released by eHealth on Thursday morning.

The health insurance exchange reported a 87% year-over-year increase in the amount of MA and Medicare Part D applications received during the open enrollment period (OEP) that lasted from January to March.

2019 marked the first year that consumers enrolled in a MA plan could switch to a different MA plan during OEP or leave MA and supplement their original Medicare coverage with a Part D prescription drug plan.  

Related: Medicare Advantage Dual Eligibles Have Fewer ER Visits Than Those Under FFS

Between 2011 and 2018, consumers weren't able to switch to a MA plan outside of the fall OEP unless they had "a circumstance that allowed you a Special Enrollment Period."

Despite the opportunity for additional coverage options, including those with lower average monthly premiums, 51% of respondents did not know about OEP prior to shopping for a new plan, according to eHealth.

Those surveyed gave several responses for why they switched to a new Medicare plan, including unhappiness with a former insurer, increased copays, doctor leaving network, and changes to drug coverage.

During the OEP, the average monthly for MA plans was $8, down from $12 in Q1 2018, while the average out-of-pocket limits decreased 11%, from $5,815 to $5,164.

Similarly, average monthly premiums for Part D plans decreased 4%.

Related: 13.3M Americans Spent More than 10% of Income on Premiums

When researchers removed zero-dollar premium plans, MA coverage options that are offset with copays or deductibles rather than premiums, average monthly premiums for MA plans still fell by 13% year-over-year.

Meanwhile, the average MA deductibles decreased 13% while Part D plan deductibles increased 5%, from $292 to $308.

Timing also made a difference regarding costs, as average MA premiums were 27% lower for individuals who enrolled during the OEP compared to those who enrolled during the annual enrollment period (AEP). 

However, average premiums for Medicare Part D plans increased 14% for individuals who enrolled during OEP compared to those enrolled during AEP.

Jack O'Brien is the Content Team Lead and Finance Editor at HealthLeaders, an HCPro brand.

Get the latest on healthcare leadership in your inbox.