The U.S. is the only industrialized nation in which the maternal death rate has been rising. Each year, about 700 deaths are due to pregnancy, childbirth or subsequent complications, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
When someone dies while pregnant or within a year of childbirth in Illinois, that's considered a maternal death. Karen Tabb Dina is a maternal health researcher at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign who serves on a state-level committee that's trying to figure out what's killing these mothers.
The group's most recent analysis found that about 75 women in Illinois die from pregnancy-related causes each year. Consistent with national trends, Black women are at greater risk than white women, and most of the deaths were preventable.
"It's cause for alarm," Tabb Dina said. "Our country is in a crisis in terms of unnecessary maternal deaths."
In recent years, Illinois' Maternal Mortality Review Committee has urged policy changes that would remove barriers to healthcare for pregnant and postpartum women. At the top of the list: Make sure low-income moms don't lose Medicaid coverage after a baby is born. Some women lose coverage as soon as two months after giving birth.
In April, Illinois became the first state to be approved by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to extend Medicaid up to a full year after a pregnancy.
"This is tremendous," Tabb Dina said. "One of the greatest risk factors for maternal deaths is lack of access to care: not being able to access the right providers and to be seen in a timely manner."
Medicaid, the state and federal program mainly for low-income Americans, covers people with higher incomes during pregnancy — but most states kick these women off the rolls 60 days after they give birth. As a result, hundreds of thousands of women who've recently had a baby end up uninsured each year.
"Disruptions in Medicaid coverage results in higher costs and worse health outcomes," HHS Secretary Xavier Becerra said in a press briefing in April, citing a federal report on the consequences of Medicaid churning. "More than half of pregnant women in Medicaid experienced a coverage gap in the first six months of postpartum care."
With the extension of Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act, mothers in Illinois with incomes up to about double the federal poverty level can keep their coverage for a year postpartum. Several other states — including New Jersey, Georgia and Virginia — are taking similar steps.
Although the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan was passed to stimulate the economy amid the COVID-19 pandemic, it also contains a less-noticed provision addressing the postpartum coverage. For the 12 states that never expanded Medicaid under the ACA, the law provides new financial incentives for them to make Medicaid available to adults with incomes up to 138% of the federal poverty level ($12,880 for an individual, $21,960 for a family of three).
In addition, the stimulus package offers all states an easier option for extending postpartum Medicaid coverage beyond the 138% income limit. Starting in April 2022, states can file a state plan amendment to their Medicaid program — a process that has fewer roadblocks to federal approval than the traditional route of applying for a federal waiver.
Maternal health experts say extending Medicaid coverage to a full year postpartum makes sense because pregnancy-related complications — physical and mental — aren't limited to the first few months.
"Many [postpartum] health issues and health problems extend beyond the 60-day period that Medicaid is currently covering," said Dr. Rachel Bervell, an obstetrician in Seattle and co-founder of the Black OBGYN Project, which aims to raise awareness about racial injustices in maternal healthcare.
A report based on data from nine states found nearly 20% of pregnancy-associated deaths happen between 43 days and one year postpartum.
Bervell clearly recalls learning about that statistic. "It was just so jarring," she said. "It makes you worried about the 1 in 5 individuals we may be missing."
Medicaid is the largest payer for maternity care in the United States. Black women are overrepresented in the Medicaid population and are also overrepresented among those who get kicked off their plan after 60 days.
Chronic diseases — like diabetes and hypertension — are more prevalent and less well-controlled among Black women, putting them at higher risk of pregnancy-related complications.
There are also structural barriers to healthcare, such as inadequate housing, transportation and child care. Many of these barriers stem from racist and discriminatory policies, like redlining, linked to worse health outcomes. Black mothers are also more likely to be denied medication for postpartum pain.
Racial disparities in maternal health outcomes are caused by racism, not race. So the problem can't be solved, Bervell said, without addressing systemic racism in medicine and the broader society.
U.S. Rep. Robin Kelly (D-Ill.) said the racial disparities are unacceptable. She championed the state's Medicaid change and is working on other policies to improve maternal health data collection and establish national obstetric emergency protocols.
"When you look at educated Black women with money, they still die more than less-educated, less-wealthy white women," she said.
Kelly said she first became aware of the issue several years ago, when she met the family of Kira Johnson, a Black mother who died after the birth of her second child from obstetrical bleeding — one of the most common causes of maternal death in the U.S.
"I'll never forget, her [older] son walked in and saw a picture of his mother on the screen. And he said, 'There's Mommy.' And that just got to me," Kelly said. "What a heartbreak."
As the rate of maternal deaths in the U.S. has ticked upward, so has the incidence of "severe maternal morbidity," according to the CDC. Each year, an estimated 50,000 women experience dangerous, even life-threatening health complications.
Jessica Davenport-Williams, a mother in Chicago, said that, after giving birth the first time, she hemorrhaged severely and had to receive blood transfusions. She was pregnant with her second daughter around the time Serena Williams and Beyoncé were in the news because of their own serious childbirth complications.
So she advocated for herself before her next delivery.
"I wanted to make sure that every physician was well aware of my history, that they documented information in my file that would be transferred to the hospital. And I was met with resistance," she said. "They didn't feel that it was necessary. I had to push for several appointments for that to happen."
After her second daughter was born via cesarean section, Davenport-Williams hemorrhaged again.
"It became an emergency situation," she said. "It just reminded me that I could have been one of those cases … that I [almost] didn't make it."
"I don't know if I will see the change for myself, in my lifetime," she said. "But I definitely don't want my daughters to have the same story or experiences that many before them have had."
While extending Medicaid coverage is an important first step, efforts to prevent maternal death can't stop there, Tabb Dina said.
Healthcare providers need to be educated about racial inequities in medicine, she said. Screening all pregnant and postpartum women for mental illness and making sure they get treatment will also help save lives.
And more patients with experience need a seat at the table in policy discussions, she said.
"We need to understand the real lived stories of our 'near misses,'" Tabb Dina said. "What were their barriers? What were their complications?"
And then ask: What more needs to change so no child has to grow up without a mother whose death could have been prevented?
The new head of the federal agency that oversees health benefits for nearly 150 million Americans and $1 trillion in federal spending said in one of her first interviews that her top priorities will be broadening insurance coverage and ensuring health equity.
"We've seen through the pandemic what happens when people don't have health insurance and how important it is," said Chiquita Brooks-LaSure, who was confirmed by the Senate to lead the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services on May 25 and sworn in on May 27. "Our focus is going to be on making sure regulations and policies are going to be focused on improving coverage."
It is an abrupt switch from the Trump administration, which steered the agency to spearhead efforts to repeal the Affordable Care Act and scale back Medicaid, the federal-state program for those with low incomes.
Brooks-LaSure, whose agency oversees the ACA marketplaces in addition to Medicare, Medicaid and the Children's Health Insurance Program, said she is not surprised at the robust takeup of ACA insurance since President Joe Biden reopened enrollment in January. The administration announced last month that more than 1 million people had signed up already.
"Over the last couple of years, I've worked with a lot of the state-based marketplaces and we could see the difference in enrollment when the states were actively pushing coverage," she said. A former congressional and Obama administration health staffer, Brooks-LaSure most recently was managing director at the consulting firm Manatt Health. "I believe that most people who are not enrolled want" coverage but may not understand it's available or how to get it, she said. "It's about knowledge and affordability."
Brooks-LaSure also suggested the administration would support efforts in Congress to ensure coverage for the millions of Americans in the so-called Medicaid gap. Those are people in the dozen states that have not expanded Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act who earn too little to qualify for ACA marketplace coverage. Georgia Democratic Sens. Jon Ossoff and Raphael Warnock, whose GOP-led state has not expanded the program, are calling for a new federal program to cover those who fall in the gap.
Brooks-LaSure said she would prefer states use the additional incentive funding provided in the recent American Rescue Plan toward expanding their Medicaid programs, "because ideally states are able to craft policies in their own states; they're closest to the ground." But if states fail to take up the offer — none have so far — "the public option or other coverage certainly would be a strategy to make sure people in those states have coverage," she said.
Also close on her radar is dealing with the impending insolvency of the trust fund that finances a large part of the Medicare program. Last year's economic downturn and the resulting loss in employees' withholding taxes is likely to accelerate the date when Medicare's hospital insurance program will not be able to cover all its bills.
Brooks-LaSure said she is sure she and Congress will be spending time on the issue in the coming year, but those discussions could also provide an opportunity for officials to reenvision the Medicare program and consider expanding benefits. Democrats in Congress are looking at both lowering Medicare's eligibility age and adding benefits the program lacks, including dental, hearing and vision coverage.
"I hope that we, when we are looking at solvency, really focus on making sure we keep the Medicare program robust," said Brooks-LaSure. "And that may mean some changes that strengthen the program."
California Attorney General Rob Bonta, a longtime Democratic state lawmaker, comes to his new role well known for pursuing an unabashedly progressive agenda on criminal justice issues. He has pushed for legislation to eliminate cash bail and to ban for-profit prisons and detention centers. But Bonta also has a distinctive record on healthcare, successfully advancing legislation to protect consumers from so-called surprise medical bills when they inadvertently get treatment from out-of-network providers and framing environmental hazards like pollution as issues of social justice.
He was among the Democratic lawmakers leading the charge at the California Capitol to take on Big Soda, pushing to cut consumption of sugary drinks through taxes and warning labels. Such proposals so far have faltered under the influence of the soda industry.
Bonta, 49, was an infant when his family, in 1971, moved to California from the Philippines, where his parents worked as missionaries. His father, Warren Bonta, a native Californian, worked for the state for decades as a healthcare official, setting up clinics to expand access to medical care in rural and refugee communities. Rob Bonta's first elected position was to the Alameda Healthcare District, overseeing local medical services.
Appointed by Gov. Gavin Newsom this year, Bonta in April succeeded former state Attorney General Xavier Becerra, who was tapped by President Joe Biden to serve as secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. In the weeks since, Bonta has beefed up the number of lawyers working in the Department of Justice's Bureau of Environmental Justice and has created a Racial Justice Bureau that he said will play a pivotal role in ensuring equal access to healthcare for Black and Latino residents.
A graduate of Yale Law School, Bonta spent nine years as a deputy city attorney in San Francisco before his election to the state Assembly in 2012, representing Oakland and the East Bay. He was the first Filipino American elected to the California legislature, and is now the first Filipino American to serve as the state's chief law enforcement officer.
As attorney general, Bonta said he envisions a far different relationship with the Biden administration than his predecessor had with the Trump administration. Becerra emerged as one of former President Donald Trump's fiercest critics during his tenure as the state's top cop, filing more than 120 lawsuits to oppose Trump administration policies on the environment and healthcare, including leading the ongoing fight to preserve the Affordable Care Act in its case before the U.S. Supreme Court. Vice President Kamala Harris also once served as California's attorney general, and Bonta said he sees tremendous opportunity to shape a more progressive agenda on issues such as reproductive health and universal, single-payer healthcare working in concert with the new administration.
Bonta spoke with KHN about how healthcare would shape his agenda as attorney general. The interview has been edited for length and clarity.
Q: Your predecessor made healthcare a priority. Will it be one of yours?
It's going to be a top priority for me, and it was a top priority for me as a legislator. I was chair of the Assembly Health Committee or a health committee member the entire time I was there, almost nine years. Before that, I was on a healthcare district board. My very first elected office I ever had was making sure we provided true access to high-quality, affordable healthcare to the community that I served.
This is a really foundational part of who I am, and who my family is — our legacy and our values and what we stood for. I think healthcare is a right, not a privilege. It's for all, not the few.
Q: You've said you would make racial justice a priority. Do you believe racism is a public health crisis?
Yes, I do. COVID-19 revealed a lot of what was inequitable and racist about our systems — the disparate impacts that we saw, the inequity that we saw. And I think racism is not just a public health crisis — it is a public health crisis — but it also infects our economic system, it infects our criminal justice system, it infects all of our systems. And it has led to a public health crisis.
Q: What does that look like in healthcare? How does inequity show up?
It looks like making sure that in healthcare there aren't disparate impacts on communities of color. That race is not correlated to less access or less quality, and making sure that no one is left out. That can look like access to reproductive healthcare; that can look like access to real health insurance as opposed to sham health insurance plans. It can look like a charge that is inappropriately placed on a vaccine — vaccines are supposed to be free. That's something else we worked on recently.
Q: Can you elaborate?
Through a joint investigation with U.S. Health and Human Services, as well as the U.S. attorney's office, we identified that vaccines — which should be provided to individuals for free under the law — that a charge was being placed on the vaccine.
The vaccine should be universally accessible. And when that isn't being done, barriers are being put up in vulnerable communities, keeping people from their vaccine that we all need right now. That is a problem. We put out an alert and reminded people of the laws that provide free vaccines to all individuals under the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention program.
Q: What areas of environmental health might you look into?
The building of huge warehouses. In the Inland Empire, there are quite a few being built. They're being built adjacent to or in disadvantaged communities. And all the goods movement activity — and all of the emissions that are created from the goods movement — create a threat, and a risk to those communities.
Q: Like Amazon, for instance? The corporation has come under scrutiny for environmental harms associated with its sprawling warehouses.
Yeah. These warehouses have really created problems for disadvantaged communities in California. We expanded the Bureau of Environmental Justice to provide more resources and more ability to go after big polluters, and to protect communities that live at the intersection of poverty and pollution who are being forced to drink dirty water and breathe unhealthy air.
I see the role of the attorney general as standing up for everyday people who are abused or hurt and neglected or mistreated, and generally protecting the little guy from the overreach and abuse of power of the big guy.
We have more authority in the environmental realm than in many other areas. And we want to use those tools — that authority, that influence, that power — to protect communities, often low-income communities, often communities of color, who are being hurt by polluters.
Q: Becerra filed a lawsuit and sponsored legislation going after health industry mergers alleged to be anti-competitive, a practice he argues drives up healthcare prices. Will you continue to go after anti-competitive practices in healthcare?
That's definitely a priority. That's a critical tool in the toolbox that the California attorney general uniquely has to approve — or put conditions on, or not approve — proposed mergers involving a nonprofit hospital.
The lens to see that through is: How does it impact patients? How does it impact access to quality care, and cost of care? And so that is exactly why the attorney general has that role, to review these proposed mergers with an eye towards patients and communities that don't necessarily have a voice in the merger.
Q: As attorney general, do you support single-payer healthcare?
My involvement will be different. Having said that, I co-authored the single-payer bill from a few years back. And I was a co-author of this year's single-payer bill that Assemblyman Ash Kalra was leading that I think is no longer moving. [Kalra has withdrawn the bill from consideration for this year.]
I support single-payer healthcare. I support universal healthcare. I think single-payer healthcare is a way to get to that aspiration.
As the attorney general, I enforce the law. We don't have a single-payer law in California. So, I'll enforce the existing laws, which are very strong, to help make sure Californians have the most accessible, affordable, highest-quality healthcare.
Q: The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear a Mississippi abortion case that some say could threaten abortion rights at the state level. If upheld, how could that affect the abortion protections in California?
That's going to be a really important case for reproductive freedom, and important, in my view, for California to be involved in given our leadership in this space. As the case gets briefed and prepped for consideration and argument before the U.S. Supreme Court, I expect we will be very active in making arguments to the court to help guide [the justices'] thinking and their decisions.
Q: What will California's relationship with the federal government be like?
I think the posture and the relationship between the federal administration and California over the last four years are very different than what they will be for the next four.
Attorney General Becerra was the warrior and the champion that we needed, and that was necessary as we faced a full-frontal assault on California, our people, our values and our resources, and he fought back and protected us and defended us and stood up for our values time and time again.
Now, I think we have a Biden-Harris administration that largely does agree that we should have, certainly, the Affordable Care Act, that we should have reproductive freedom, that we should address the inequities in our healthcare system, that we should have affordable, accessible, high-quality healthcare for all — and will help us get there.
So, with the new administration, I look to collaboration. California can and should continue to be who we are. We lead. We go first. We pioneer. We're bold and we're big in how we think. That's who we are, so that leading role is our natural place to be, including in healthcare.
When the pandemic sidelined in-office visits at his practice, Dr. Dael Waxman "wasn't exactly thrilled with being at home." But he quickly shifted gears to video and telephone appointments.
Now, he finds, there are good reasons to keep these options open even as in-office visits have resumed and many parts of the country have sharply loosened coronavirus restrictions.
One is that some patients "have to overcome a lot of obstacles to get to me," said Waxman, a family physician with Atrium Health in Charlotte, North Carolina. "I have lots of single mothers. They have to leave work, get their kids out of school and then take two buses. Why would they want to do that if they don't have to?"
Telehealth served as a lifeline for many during the pandemic, ramping up from a minority share of office visits to a majority, at least for a while. Still, it cannot replace hands-on care for some conditions, and for those not blessed with speedy broadband internet service or smart devices it can be difficult or impossible to use.
As things head toward a new normal, lawmakers and insurers, including Medicare, are debating how to proceed, the biggest question being whether to continue reimbursing providers at the same payment rate as for in-person coverage once the COVID public health emergency end.
While that debate rages — one side pointing to the costs associated with setting up such services, the other arguing that payment rates should decline because telehealth services are cheaper to provide — patients are left to decide if such visits meet their needs.
KHN put such questions to physicians, who gave tips on the types of concerns that are best handled in person, and when video visits are most useful. Not surprisingly, they recommended that patients ask their provider which type of visit is most appropriate for their particular circumstance.
Four additional things we learned:
1. Some things just need to be done in person.
Chest pains, new shortness of breath, abdominal pain, new or increased swelling in the legs — all those things point to the need for an in-person visit. And, of course, blood tests, vaccinations and imaging scans must be done in person.
"If your blood pressure is really high or you have some symptoms of concern like chest pain, one needs to go to the office," said Dr. Ada Stewart, president of the American Academy of Family Physicians, which posted an online guide for telemedicine visits.
If patients are concerned enough about the situation that they are considering going to an urgent care clinic or even an emergency room, "they should be seen," said Waxman. And that would occur in person.
If a condition, even something seemingly simple, hasn't resolved in a reasonable time, go to the office. Waxman recalled a patient with an eye issue who went to urgent care and received antibiotics, but the eye was still irritated after treatment.
"Because it had not resolved, I was worried about shingles of the eye," he said. It turned out not to be shingles, but a different problem, Waxman learned after referring the patient to an ophthalmologist.
In-person visits can also prove more productive because a physician gains visual clues to what might be wrong by watching how a patient walks, sits or speaks.
While video visits are wonderful, said Dr. David Anderson, a cardiologist affiliated with Stanford Health Care in Oakland, California, sometimes things come up in person that might not over video.
"I can't say how many times I sit with a patient and I think we're done — then the thing that's really the problem gets brought up and we spend the next 45 minutes on it," he said.
Finally, a good reason to go in is, simply, if that's what you prefer.
"I had a patient the other day who said he could have done a phone visit but was old-school and just preferred being in the office," Waxman said.
2. Sometimes a televisit is better.
It's not always necessary to trek into a medical office or clinic.
Stewart, at the family physician group, said check-ins for chronic conditions, such as diabetes or hypertension, "that are basically under control" can easily be handled remotely.
Cardiologist Anderson concurred, especially for periodic assessments or checking how a patient is handling a new medication.
"If I have a [stable] 82-year-old patient and her daughter needs to miss work and come from 30 miles away to bring Mom in for us to sit there for 15 minutes to chat, that's something where the efficiency of a video visit is good," he said. But if that same patient complains that "when they take a morning walk, they are short of breath and they were not before, that person I would want to see face to face."
And, sometimes, video follow-ups for stable patients with chronic illnesses are preferable. "On the phone or by video, I found there to be a lot more non-distracted time for education," he said.
It is helpful if patients can monitor their blood sugar or blood pressure at home and then report their statistics during the televisit.
But some patients cannot afford a home blood pressure monitor, so that can be a limitation, Waxman cautioned. And even those who have a monitor should initially take it into the office to make sure it is accurate, he said.
Some dermatologic conditions — think rashes and such — can be handled by video, so long as the patient is comfortable using the camera on their smartphone or computer tablet and can get a good picture of the problem area. While 70% to 80% of skin issues can start with a video visit, he estimated, the rest require in-person evaluation, perhaps even a biopsy.
3. Everything works better when both sides prepare.
Both patients and providers can get the most out of a video visit if they first take a few simple steps, the experts said.
Find a quiet place without distractions. Turn off the TV. Have a family member present if you want a second set of ears, but choose a private setting if you don't.
"You will not believe the circumstances where people Zoom in to me," said Anderson.
Some are in their cars, "maybe because that's the best place where they get internet service," or they're in their pajamas, just finishing breakfast.
"There's a whole lack of preparation and seriousness that occurs," he said.
Have a list of medications you're taking and write down the problem or symptoms you wish to discuss, as well as specific questions you have, to make the most out of the time available, advised Stewart.
Providers, too, need to take steps.
Anderson said they should read patients' medical records ahead of time and focus because there are fewer cues to a patient's concerns over video than in person.
Physicians "have to be doubly vigilant," Anderson said, pay attention to all their suspicions and be extra thorough because "it would be much easier to miss something important."
4. What might happen next?
Some advocates say insurers should make sure that their reimbursement policies don't favor one type of visit over another and that no patient feels pressured into a televisit.
During the COVID emergency, Congress and the agency that oversees Medicare temporarily made it easier for beneficiaries to use telehealth — for instance, by removing geographic restrictions and allowing audio-only visits in some circumstances. Medicare also began reimbursing providers equally for telehealth and in-person care.
Many private insurers followed Medicare's lead; some also voluntarily waived cost-sharing requirements for telehealth patients.
Many expect Medicare Advantage plans to keep covering televisits once the emergency is officially over, and traditional Medicare could follow suit. The Medicare Payment Advisory Commission, a nonpartisan agency that advises Congress, has recommended temporarily continuing to cover some services while the agency gathers data about a wide range of effects, including concerns that telehealth raises spending and the advantages it may offer.
That data is important, said Fred Riccardi, president of the Medicare Rights Center. The expansion has helped many Medicare beneficiaries, he added, but "has left some communities behind," including the oldest adults, those with disabilities and those in areas with spotty internet service. And future policies should ensure that patients who prefer in-person visits can continue them, he said.
Anderson, the cardiologist, agreed that televisits "have a wonderful place" in the range of options, but he warned against cost-saving measures by insurers that might require patients to have a video visit before being granted coverage for an office visit.
"I would see that as an unfortunate delay in care," he said.
With nearly 600,000 in the U.S. lost to COVID-19 — now a leading cause of death — researchers estimate that more than 5 million Americans are in mourning.
This article was published on Wednesday, June 2, 2021 in Kaiser Health News.
Cassandra Rollins' daughter was still conscious when the ambulance took her away.
Shalondra Rollins, 38, was struggling to breathe as COVID overwhelmed her lungs. But before the doors closed, she asked for her cellphone, so she could call her family from the hospital.
It was April 7, 2020 — the last time Rollins would see her daughter or hear her voice.
The hospital rang an hour later to say she was gone. A chaplain later told Rollins that Shalondra had died on a gurney in the hallway. Rollins was left to break the news to Shalondra's children, ages 13 and 15.
More than a year later, Rollins said, the grief is unrelenting.
Rollins has suffered panic attacks and depression that make it hard to get out of bed. She often startles when the phone rings, fearing that someone else is hurt or dead. If her other daughters don't pick up when she calls, Rollins phones their neighbors to check on them.
"You would think that as time passes it would get better," said Rollins, 57, of Jackson, Mississippi. "Sometimes, it is even harder. … This wound right here, time don't heal it."
The pandemic — and the political battles and economic devastation that have accompanied it — have inflicted unique forms of torment on mourners, making it harder to move ahead with their lives than with a typical loss, said sociologist Holly Prigerson, co-director of the Cornell Center for Research on End-of-Life Care.
The scale and complexity of pandemic-related grief have created a public health burden that could deplete Americans' physical and mental health for years, leading to more depression, substance misuse, suicidal thinking, sleep disturbances, heart disease, cancer, high blood pressure and impaired immune function.
"Unequivocally, grief is a public health issue," said Prigerson, who lost her mother to COVID in January. "You could call it the grief pandemic."
Like many other mourners, Rollins has struggled with feelings of guilt, regret and helplessness — for the loss of her daughter as well as Rollins' only son, Tyler, who died by suicide seven months earlier.
"I was there to see my mom close her eyes and leave this world," said Rollins, who was first interviewed by KHN a year ago in a story about COVID's disproportionate effects on communities of color. "The hardest part is that my kids died alone. If it weren't for this COVID, I could have been right there with her" in the ambulance and emergency room. "I could have held her hand."
The pandemic has prevented many families from gathering and holding funerals, even after deaths caused by conditions other than COVID. Prigerson's research shows that families of patients who die in hospital intensive care units are seven times more likely to develop post-traumatic stress disorder than loved ones of people who die in home hospice.
The polarized political climate has even pitted some family members against one another, with some insisting that the pandemic is a hoax and that loved ones must have died from influenza, rather than COVID. People in grief say they're angry at relatives, neighbors and fellow Americans who failed to take the coronavirus seriously, or who still don't appreciate how many people have suffered.
"People holler about not being able to have a birthday party," Rollins said. "We couldn't even have a funeral."
Indeed, the optimism generated by vaccines and falling infection rates has blinded many Americans to the deep sorrow and depression of those around them. Some mourners say they will continue wearing their face masks — even in places where mandates have been removed — as a memorial to those lost.
"People say, 'I can't wait until life gets back to normal,'" said Heidi Diaz Goff, 30, of the Los Angeles area, who lost her 72-year-old father to COVID. "My life will never be normal again."
Many of those grieving say celebrating the end of the pandemic feels not just premature, but insulting to their loved ones' memories.
"Grief is invisible in many ways," said Tashel Bordere, a University of Missouri assistant professor of human development and family science who studies bereavement, particularly in the Black community. "When a loss is invisible and people can't see it, they may not say 'I'm sorry for your loss,' because they don't know it's occurred."
Communities of color, which have experienced disproportionately higher rates of death and job loss from COVID, are now carrying a heavier burden.
Black children are more likely than white children to lose a parent to COVID. Even before the pandemic, the combination of higher infant and maternal mortality rates, a greater incidence of chronic disease and shorter life expectancies made Black people more likely than others to be grieving a close family member at any point in their lives.
Rollins said everyone she knows has lost someone to COVID.
"You wake up every morning, and it's another day they're not here," Rollins said. "You go to bed at night, and it's the same thing."
A Lifetime of Loss
Rollins has been battered by hardships and loss since childhood.
She was the youngest of 11 children raised in the segregated South. Rollins was 5 years old when her older sister Cora, whom she called "Coral," was stabbed to death at a nightclub, according to news reports. Although Cora's husband was charged with murder, he was set free after a mistrial.
Rollins gave birth to Shalondra at age 17, and the two were especially close. "We grew up together," Rollins said.
Just a few months after Shalondra was born, Rollins' older sister Christine was fatally shot during an argument with another woman. Rollins and her mother helped raise two of the children Christine left behind.
Heartbreak is all too common in the Black community, Bordere said. The accumulated trauma — from violence to chronic illness and racial discrimination — can have a weathering effect, making it harder for people to recover.
"It's hard to recover from any one experience, because every day there is another loss," Bordere said. "Grief impacts our ability to think. It impacts our energy levels. Grief doesn't just show up in tears. It shows up in fatigue, in working less."
Rollins hoped her children would overcome the obstacles of growing up Black in Mississippi. Shalondra earned an associate's degree in early childhood education and loved her job as an assistant teacher to kids with special needs. Shalondra, who had been a second mother to her younger siblings, also adopted a cousin's stepdaughter after the child's mother died, raising the girl alongside her two children.
Rollins' son, Tyler, enlisted in the Army after high school, hoping to follow in the footsteps of other men in the family who had military careers.
Yet the hardest losses of Rollins' life were still to come. In 2019, Tyler killed himself at age 20, leaving behind a wife and unborn child.
"When you see two Army men walking up to your door," Rollins said, "that's unexplainable."
Tyler's daughter was born the day Shalondra died.
"They called to tell me the baby was born, and I had to tell them about Shalondra," Rollins said. "I don't know how to celebrate."
Shalondra's death from COVID changed her daughters' lives in multiple ways.
The girls lost their mother, but also the routines that might help mourners adjust to a catastrophic loss. The girls moved in with their grandmother, who lives in their school district. But they have not set foot in a classroom for more than a year, spending their days in virtual school, rather than with friends.
Shalondra's death eroded their financial security as well, by taking away her income. Rollins, who worked as a substitute teacher before the pandemic, hasn't had a job since local schools shut down. She owns her own home and receives unemployment insurance, she said, but money is tight.
Makalin Odie, 14, said her mother, as a teacher, would have made online learning easier. "It would be very different with my mom here."
The girls especially miss their mom on holidays.
"My mom always loved birthdays," said Alana Odie, 16. "I know that if my mom were here my 16th birthday would have been really special."
Asked what she loved most about her mother, Alana replied, "I miss everything about her."
Grief Complicated by Illness
The trauma also has taken a toll on Alana and Makalin's health. Both teens have begun taking medications for high blood pressure. Alana has been on diabetes medication since before her mom died.
Mental and physical health problems are common after a major loss. "The mental health consequences of the pandemic are real," Prigerson said. "There are going to be all sorts of ripple effects."
The stress of losing a loved one to COVID increases the risk for prolonged grief disorder, also known as complicated grief, which can lead to serious illness, increase the risk of domestic violence and steer marriages and relationships to fall apart, said Ashton Verdery, an associate professor of sociology and demography at Penn State.
Grief can lead to "broken-heart syndrome," a temporary condition in which the heart's main pumping chamber changes shape, affecting its ability to pump blood effectively, Verdery said.
From final farewells to funerals, the pandemic has robbed mourners of nearly everything that helps people cope with catastrophic loss, while piling on additional insults, said the Rev. Alicia Parker, minister of comfort at New Covenant Church of Philadelphia.
"It may be harder for them for many years to come," Parker said. "We don't know the fallout yet, because we are still in the middle of it."
Rollins said she would have liked to arrange a big funeral for Shalondra. Because of restrictions on social gatherings, the family held a small graveside service instead.
Funerals are important cultural traditions, allowing loved ones to give and receive support for a shared loss, Parker said.
"When someone dies, people bring food for you, they talk about your loved one, the pastor may come to the house," Parker said. "People come from out of town. What happens when people can't come to your home and people can't support you? Calling on the phone is not the same."
While many people are afraid to acknowledge depression, because of the stigma of mental illness, mourners know they can cry and wail at a funeral without being judged, Parker said.
"What happens in the African American house stays in the house," Parker said. "There's a lot of things we don't talk about or share about."
Funerals play an important psychological role in helping mourners process their loss, Bordere said. The ritual helps mourners move from denying that a loved one is gone to accepting "a new normal in which they will continue their life in the physical absence of the cared-about person." In many cases, death from COVID comes suddenly, depriving people of a chance to mentally prepare for loss. While some families were able to talk to loved ones through FaceTime or similar technologies, many others were unable to say goodbye.
Funerals and burial rites are especially important in the Black community and others that have been marginalized, Bordere said.
"You spare no expense at a Black funeral," Bordere said. "The broader culture may have devalued this person, but the funeral validates this person's worth in a society that constantly tries to dehumanize them."
In the early days of the pandemic, funeral directors afraid of spreading the coronavirus did not allow families to provide clothing for their loved ones' burials, Parker said. So beloved parents and grandparents were buried in whatever they died in, such as undershirts or hospital gowns.
"They bag them and double-bag them and put them in the ground," Parker said. "It is an indignity."
Coping With Loss
Every day, something reminds Rollins of her losses.
April brought the first anniversary of Shalondra's death. May brought Teacher Appreciation Week.
Yet Rollins said the memory of her children keeps her going.
When she begins to cry and thinks she will never stop, one thought pulls her from the darkness: "I know they would want me to be happy. I try to live on that."
The day Dr. Elizabeth Dawson was diagnosed with covid-19 in October, she awoke feeling as if she had a bad hangover. Four months later she tested negative for the virus, but her symptoms have only worsened.
Dawson is among what one doctor called “waves and waves” of “long-haul” covid patients who remain sick long after retesting negative for the virus. A significant percentage are suffering from syndromes that few doctors understand or treat. In fact, a yearlong wait to see a specialist for these syndromes was common even before the ranks of patients were swelled by post-covid newcomers. For some, the consequences are life altering.
Before fall, Dawson, 44, a dermatologist from Portland, Oregon, routinely saw 25 to 30 patients a day, cared for her 3-year-old daughter and ran long distances.
Today, her heart races when she tries to stand. She has severe headaches, constant nausea and brain fog so extreme that, she said, it “feels like I have dementia.” Her fatigue is severe: “It’s as if all the energy has been sucked from my soul and my bones.” She can’t stand for more than 10 minutes without feeling dizzy.
Through her own research, Dawson recognized she had typical symptoms of postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, or POTS. It is a disorder of the autonomic nervous system, which controls involuntary functions such as heart rate, blood pressure and vein contractions that assist blood flow. It is a serious condition — not merely feeling lightheaded on rising suddenly, which affects many patients who have been confined to bed a long time with illnesses like covid as their nervous system readjusts to greater activity. POTS sometimes overlaps with autoimmune problems, which involve the immune system attacking healthy cells. Before covid, an estimated 3 million Americans had POTS.
Many POTS patients report it took them years to even find a diagnosis. With her own suspected diagnosis in hand, Dawson soon discovered there were no specialists in autonomic disorders in Portland — in fact, there are only 75 board-certified autonomic disorder doctors in the U.S.
Other doctors, however, have studied and treat POTS and similar syndromes. The nonprofit organization Dysautonomia International provides a list of a handful of clinics and about 150 U.S. doctors who have been recommended by patients and agreed to be on the list.
In January, Dawson called a neurologist at a Portland medical center where her father had worked and was given an appointment for September. She then called Stanford University Medical Center’s autonomic clinic in California, and again was offered an appointment nine months later.
Using contacts in the medical community, Dawson wrangled an appointment with the Portland neurologist within a week and was diagnosed with POTS and chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). The two syndromes have overlapping symptoms, often including severe fatigue.
Dr. Peter Rowe of Johns Hopkins in Baltimore, a prominent researcher who has treated POTS and CFS patients for 25 years, said every doctor with expertise in POTS is seeing long-haul covid patients with POTS, and every long-covid patient he has seen with CFS also had POTS. He expects the lack of medical treatment to worsen.
“Decades of neglect of POTS and CFS have set us up to fail miserably,” said Rowe, one of the authors of a recent paper on CFS triggered by covid.
The prevalence of POTS was documented in an international survey of 3,762 long-covid patients, leading researchers to conclude that all covid patients who have rapid heartbeat, dizziness, brain fog or fatigue “should be screened for POTS.”
A “significant infusion of health care resources and a significant additional research investment” will be needed to address the growing caseload, the American Autonomic Society said in a recent statement.
Lauren Stiles, who founded Dysautonomia International in 2012 after being diagnosed with POTS, said patients who have suffered for decades worry about “the growth of people who need testing and treating but the lack of growth in doctors skilled in autonomic nervous system disorders.”
On the other hand, she hopes increasing awareness among physicians will at least get patients with dysautonomia diagnosed quickly, rather than years later.
Congress has allocated $1.5 billion to the National Institutes of Health over the next four years to study post-covid conditions. Requests for proposals have already been issued.
“There is hope that this miserable experience with covid will be valuable,” said Dr. David Goldstein, head of NIH’s Autonomic Medicine Section.
A unique opportunity for advances in treatment, he said, exists because researchers can study a large sample of people who got the same virus at roughly the same time, yet some recovered and some did not.
Long-term symptoms are common. A University of Washington study published in February in the Journal of the American Medical Association’s Network Open found that 27% of covid survivors ages 18-39 had persistent symptoms three to nine months after testing negative for covid. The percentage was slightly higher for middle-aged patients, and 43% for patients 65 and over.
The most common complaint: persistent fatigue. A Mayo Clinic study published last month found that 80% of long-haulers complained of fatigue and nearly half of “brain fog.” Less common symptoms are inflamed heart muscles, lung function abnormalities and acute kidney problems.
Larger studies remain to be conducted. However, “even if only a tiny percentage of the millions who contracted covid suffer long-term consequences,” said Rowe, “we’re talking a huge influx of patients, and we don’t have the clinical capacity to take care of them.”
Symptoms of autonomic dysfunction are showing up in patients who had mild, moderate or severe covid symptoms.
Yet even today, some physicians discount conditions like POTS and CFS, both much more common in women than men. With no biomarkers, these syndromes are sometimes considered psychological.
The experience of POTS patient Jaclyn Cinnamon, 31, is typical. She became ill in college 13 years ago. The Illinois resident, now on the patient advisory board of Dysautonomia International, saw dozens of doctors seeking an explanation for her racing heart, severe fatigue, frequent vomiting, fever and other symptoms. For years, without results, she saw specialists in infectious disease, cardiology, allergies, rheumatoid arthritis, endocrinology and alternative medicine — and a psychiatrist, “because some doctors clearly thought I was simply a hysterical woman.”
It took three years for her to be diagnosed with POTS. The test is simple: Patients lie down for five minutes and have their blood pressure and heart rate taken. They then either stand or are tilted to 70-80 degrees and their vital signs are retaken. The heart rate of those with POTS will increase by at least 30 beats per minute, and often as much as 120 beats per minute within 10 minutes. POTS and CFS symptoms range from mild to debilitating.
The doctor who diagnosed Cinnamon told her he didn’t have the expertise to treat POTS. Nine years after the onset of the illness, she finally received treatment that alleviated her symptoms. Although there are no federally approved drugs for POTS or CFS, experienced physicians use a variety of medicines including fludrocortisone, commonly prescribed for Addison’s disease, that can improve symptoms. Some patients are also helped by specialized physical therapy that first involves a therapist assisting with exercises while the patient is lying down, then later the use of machines that don’t require standing, such as rowing machines and recumbent exercise bicycles. Some recover over time; some do not.
Dawson said she can’t imagine the “darkness” experienced by patients who lack her access to a network of health care professionals. A retired endocrinologist urged her to have her adrenal function checked. Dawson discovered that her glands were barely producing cortisol, a hormone critical to vital body functions.
Medical progress, she added, is everyone’s best hope.
Stiles, whose organization funds research and provides physician and patient resources, is optimistic.
“Never in history has every major medical center in the world been studying the same disease at the same time with such urgency and collaboration,” she said. “I’m hoping we’ll understand covid and post-covid syndrome in record time.”
Mississippi had already narrowed an outsize gap in covid-19 incidence and mortality rates for its Black residents, leveraging community partnerships to promote masks and physical distancing while dispelling rumors.
This article was published on Sunday, May 30, 2021 in Kaiser Health News.
At its first pop-up vaccination event on April 10, the Northeast Mississippi Coalition Against Covid 19 gave shots to nearly 40 people in Shannon, a town where roughly 60% of some 1,800 residents are African American.
Though a fraction of the doses typically given out at large mass vaccination sites, the event was a success, say organizers — a coalition of health care providers and elected officials. Held outdoors, it allowed for a physically distant, communal atmosphere that many have missed over the past year.
“People would get their shot, and then say, ‘I’m going to get my wife or my daughter,’” said Dr. Vernon Rayford, a Tupelo internal medicine physician and coalition member.
The group has held two more events and administered a total of 110 doses, Rayford said. More pop-ups are scheduled.
Mississippi had already narrowed an outsize gap in covid-19 incidence and mortality rates for its Black residents, leveraging community partnerships to promote masks and physical distancing while dispelling rumors. Now health advocates hope to stretch those partnerships to help ensure vaccines reach all Mississippians equally.
It appears to be working. Vaccine rates are neck and neck among Black and white residents, with available state data showing a slightly higher rate for whites and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data showing the opposite. Mississippi is one of the few states where the Black rate isn’t lagging significantly behind the rate for whites.
And as of mid-May, African Americans, who make up 38% of the state’s population, are getting 40% of the doses given each week, said state epidemiologist Dr. Paul Byers.
“We continue to reach parity with our doses,” Byers said during a May press conference.
This is the latest phase of Mississippi’s dramatic turnaround on covid among its Black residents.
In the first four months of the pandemic, the incidence of covid was almost three times higher for African Americans than whites — 1,131 cases per 100,000 for Black Mississippians compared with 403 cases per 100,000 for whites. Mortality in those first months was almost twice as high for African Americans — 46.2 per 100,000 compared with 24.6 per 100,000 for whites, based on an analysis of weekly covid reports published by the Mississippi State Department of Health.
“Covid revealed what many already knew in the public health community: that the inequities in Black and brown communities have existed for a long time,” said Victor Sutton, who directs the state health department’s preventive health and health equity division.
That disproportionate toll on Black Mississippians started to wane, though, as covid cases began a rapid climb in the state and the rest of the country in the fall. Public health officials saw per capita rates of infection and deaths for African Americans drop below the rates of the white population. Through the peak of the holiday covid wave in mid-January, the infections and deaths rose for both groups, but the rates for African Americans remained lower than for whites.
State health department officials pointed to outreach through churches, historically black colleges and universities and community organizations that reinforced the importance of masking and physical distancing among African Americans. Efforts were also underway to reach other underserved groups, including Hispanics across the state, Native Americans in eastern Mississippi and Vietnamese communities on the Gulf Coast.
While Mississippi was among the first states to drop its mask rules, the groups hit hardest by the pandemic were more open to masking and physical distancing than the overall population, health officials said.
“It didn’t get political in the African American community,” Rayford said.
In Tupelo, the Temple of Compassion and Deliverance’s Bishop Clarence Parks was among the Mississippi clergy who used his pulpit both in his church and on Facebook. He lost his 91-year-old mother to covid on April 9, 2020. Hers was among the first cases diagnosed in Tupelo.
“It did give me a sense of urgency,” Parks said. “I saw what covid was doing.”
In addition to moving church services online and into the parking lot, Parks made a point to talk to his congregation about how to protect themselves, their parents and grandparents from covid. As small groups came back inside the church, masks were required. He talked to other pastors about safeguarding their flocks. Parks, 61, posted on Facebook when he got his covid vaccine.
In his congregation of 400, Parks estimates about 15 became infected with covid.
“My mom is the only one in our church who passed from covid,” Parks said.
Mississippi Valley State University, a historically Black school in Itta Bena, a town in the Mississippi Delta, hosted drives to distribute masks and information on protective measures, plus hosted Zoom community meetings to reach beyond its campus boundaries.
“We’re trying to focus on the Delta,” said La Shon Brooks, chief of staff and legislative liaison for the Mississippi Valley president.
Parity on vaccines, though, got off to a slow start. When supply was limited and appointments were snapped up in minutes in February, African Americans were receiving about 15% of the vaccines distributed through the state health department. As more vaccine became available, the department started sending thousands of doses to community health centers and clinics serving large minority populations, said State Health Officer Dr. Thomas Dobbs.
“We want to make sure we‘re addressing trust and access issues,” Dobbs said during a February press conference.
In southwestern Mississippi, Alcorn State University, a historically Black school, organized a vaccine clinic in partnership with the state health department and local county emergency management agency. Located in a rural county with the closest hospitals about 45 minutes away by car, the university has attracted between 160 and 200 Mississippians to each drive-in clinic session. The organizers even made walk-up appointments available to reach students and staff members on campus.
“We’re drawing a wide range of ages and races,” said Jennifer Riley Collins, Alcorn State’s covid response coordinator.
In recent weeks, the state health department has increased efforts to partner with community groups on smaller vaccination events and to reach the homebound. They are also working to direct the public to pharmacies and clinics offering the vaccine.
Health advocates remain concerned that more Mississippians of all races and ethnicities need to be vaccinated or the state risks another wave of infections that could overwhelm health care resources.
In survey results released in mid-May, the Mississippi State Health Department, which polled 11,000 state residents across all 82 counties between December and March, found that 73% were likely to take the vaccine, but as of Thursday only 33.7% of the state’s residents had rolled up their sleeves for at least one dose, according to CDC data. Nationwide, the rate was 49.9%.
Among African Americans, the survey found 56% intended to get vaccinated, compared with 80% of white Mississippians.
“We’re still at risk,” Dobbs said. “We still have a large part of the population that is still vulnerable.”
Even as racial equity in vaccine distribution has improved, closing the gap among the still hesitant and skeptical remains a significant challenge to achieving widespread immunity.
Health care workers, ranked as top vaccine influencers in the health department survey, will need to switch out of their traditional role of giving monologues and engage instead in a dialogue to understand what is preventing the unvaccinated from getting the shots, said Dr. Jeremy Blanchard, chief medical officer for Tupelo-based North Mississippi Health Services.
“We need to listen more effectively,” Blanchard said.
Nykerrius Williams knows about the close relationship between hip-hop and opioid use. Williams, 27, an independent rapper from Gibsland, Louisiana, who goes by the name Young Nyke, took oxycodone pills for the first time when he was 16 and has continued patterns of misuse of those pills, as well as Lortabs, Xanax and codeine cough syrups, until recently. To him, it's part of the business.
"If you ain't rapping about being on no drugs, or you out here in the streets selling some drugs," he said of his chosen profession, "you ain't got some of that going on — like, don't nobody wanna hear what you talking about."
This snapshot of Williams' hip-hop life doesn't seem all that different from that of musicians of other genres for whom the mix of drugs and addiction is a recurring storyline, claiming the lives of artists like Janis Joplin, found dead of a heroin overdose in 1970, and rapper DMX, who died last month.
But drug use in the hip-hop community has an ever increasing presence that is intertwined with the music – and one with dire consequences. The catchy lyrics suggest that opioid misuse is part and parcel with fame and wealth, just a normal, and innocuous, component of that life.
Coverage on the abuse of hard drugs in the community usually focuses on tragedy surrounding certain popular rappers rather than the lyrics and the culture they create. And while public health experts take great pains, for example, to criticize and curtail the promotion of vaping to young people, little attention is paid to the dangerous effects that hip-hop is having on vulnerable listeners by normalizing popping Percocets or drinking cough syrup.
From big cities like Los Angeles to rural towns like Gibsland — population 878 — opioid misuse among some young, hopeful listeners is about emulating their favorite rap star's enviable image. For others, it is not all about the high life. It's self-medication.
"Let's talk about pain," said Mikiel Muhammad, 38, aka King Kong Gotcha, a member of the rap trio The Opioid Era in Virginia. "The pain is so deep. They ain't got money to go see a psychiatrist, but they got money to go get a Perc-10. They got $10, $15 for that," Gotcha said, referencing the street value of a 10-milligram Percocet tablet.
According to a February KFF report, anxiety, depression and thoughts of suicide have increased for young adults in the past year.
Artists like Young Nyke sometimes confront neighborhood and family violence, as well as a general lack of opportunities and resources in their communities — circumstances amplified by the COVID pandemic. The poetic words detailing the rappers' experience offer some support. But these phrases can also be fraught.
It's not just the drug use that is worrisome, said Naa-Solo Tettey, an associate professor of public health at William Paterson University in Wayne, New Jersey. Often these songs promote using opioids while engaging in high-risk activities like unprotected sex or speeding and, while she is a hip-hop fan, "from a public health perspective, it's just dangerous," she said.
That toxicity reaches into populations already plagued by perpetual cycles of poverty, poor health and lowered life expectancy. There is a need for "culturally relevant interventions" to educate and raise awareness within the hip-hop music audience, which Tettey's research categorizes as primarily composed of youth from "vulnerable and socially disadvantaged" groups.
It is time to turn a critical eye to how opioid misuse permeates hip-hop's lyrics, creating an entryway for Black young adults into the American opioid epidemic, said Tettey.
In 2017 that epidemic was declared a national public health emergency, with over 47,000 opioid-related overdose deaths reported. Researchers at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention say fatal drug overdoses nationwide have surged roughly 20% during the COVID pandemic, killing more than 83,000 people in 2020. Within this grim statistic the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration has found inequities.
According to a 2020 report from the Department of Health and Human Services' Office of Behavioral Health Equity and SAMHSA, attention to this crisis has focused more on white suburban and rural communities, even though Black communities are experiencing similar dramatic increases in opioid misuse and death. The report also found that synthetic opioids, like fentanyl, are affecting opioid death rates among Black people more severely than other populations.
A 2020 SAGE journal research paper found a large increase in prescription opioid overdose deaths among Black people. The paper also found the rate of death almost tripling between 1999 and 2017. In February 2018 the U.S. surgeon general tweeted a warning that trends in opioid misuse "may be a precursor to even more opioid overdose fatalities in the black community in coming years."
"The music industry, all it does is perpetuate whatever's going on outside," said Jarrell Gilliard, 40, explaining the pharmaceutical drug presence he's encountered and how it's reflected in popular lyrics. "How they pump these pills and all these prescribed medicines through the streets. Once the streets got 'em …" said Gilliard, whose hip-hop alias is Grunge Gallardo.
Grunge is also a member of The Opioid Era, named for their gritty, raw imagery and lyrics. Songs such as "Suboxones," "Sackler Oath" and "Overdose," which opens with a haunting 911 recording of a woman frantically pleading for help with one, contrast sharply with the pill-laced tunes of hip-hop's mainstream.
"I think that's the most dangerous thing about it," said Richard Buskey, 42, who completes The Opioid Era trio as Ambassador Rick. "It's a disconnect between the youth and them realizing that they're in the same category as what they would consider a junkie or a fiend."
Tettey said that's partly because mainstream artists represent a lifestyle many young adults want for themselves, which can translate into modeling behaviors like opioid misuse.
Feeling the 'Lean'
Patrick Williams, 26, an independent rapper from Orange, Texas, with the stage name PatvFoo, is no stranger to addiction.
He was 21 when he first sipped "lean" — a drink made from mixing prescription cough syrup containing the antihistamine promethazine and the opioid codeine with soda, Jolly Rancher candies and ice, served in doubled-up Styrofoam cups. "It's a variety of colors that you have," PatvFoo said, referencing the various formulations of codeine cough syrups. Purple syrup ranks as most potent. PatvFoo learned about lean through the Texas rap scene and artists like DJ Screw and then became a user.
"At first, there's a mellowing high," said Stevie Jones, 23, also known as Prophet J, an independent rapper in Louisville, Kentucky. He has similar recollections from his first time misusing codeine syrups. He and his friends drizzled some on a blunt — the slang term for a hollowed-out cigar filled with pot. "It just makes it burn slower — like, get you a little bit higher, I guess," Prophet J said.
Things can take a bad turn quickly. Although lean is one of the weaker opioids, experts say it is highly addictive, and often in a short time. "The day you go without it you get bad, bad stomach cramps. You feel like you got to just throw up all the time. You sweating. It's like you got a bad flu," PatvFoo said.
That flu-like feeling is opioid withdrawal, said Dr. Edwin C. Chapman, a Howard University College of Medicine alum who has practiced internal and addiction medicine in Washington, D.C., for more than 40 years. The symptoms range from runny nose and eyes to diarrhea and usually can be stopped with a gulp of cough syrup or lean, he said.
And there's a harsh reality in that. Whether it's Percocet pills or lean, "it's all in the same class as heroin and fentanyl," Chapman said.
But learning that opioid use is promoted in popular music came as a revelation to Chapman. "That's not the music that I listened to," said the 75-year-old doctor. The medical community, he said, has been focused on curbing the overprescribing of pain medication. "But it's never talked about … that it's being advertised overtly to young folks through music or through the media."
Indeed, abuse of lean, also known as "purple drank" and "sizzurp," has managed to evade the regulatory spotlight while remaining popular and recognizable — so much so that vaping companies distributed nicotine-containing e-liquids resembling the drink and even mimicked the slang term "double cup" in their labeling. These products triggered a 2019 Food and Drug Administration crackdown on the vaping juices. The drugs themselves, however, still pump through the streets, just like the hip-hop lyrics.
And it has altered the market, moving it beyond the street options of heroin and opioids, said hip-hop artist Buskey. "We living in the times where they're getting it out of the medicine cabinet."
Phillip Coleman, 34, a rapper in Rochester, New York, who goes by the name GodclouD, started using at age 15 after being prescribed 5-milligram tablets of Percocet following wisdom tooth extraction. That set him on a path to misusing prescription painkillers, which led to cocaine and then a heroin addiction that eventually landed him in prison.
Fortunately, Coleman was able to overcome his addictions in rehab and refocus on family and music. He cautions that people buying Percocet or other prescription pills on the street have no way of knowing if they are legitimate or "just pressed fentanyl." He said the reward for opioid addiction isn't the lifestyles of the rich and famous you see portrayed by some hip-hop artists. "You don't get to trade in your empty bags like the box tops and get, like, a bike or whatever. Like, you don't get no hat; you don't get no fentanyl swag," he chuckled. "Like, you just die."
The number of Americans 65 and older is expected to nearly double in the next 40 years. Finding a way to provide and pay for the long-term health services they need won't be easy.
This article was published on Friday, May 28, 2021 in Kaiser Health News.
Healthcare for the nation's seniors looms large as the baby-boom generation ages into retirement. President Joe Biden tacitly acknowledged those needs in March with his proposal to spend $400 billion over the next eight years to improve access to in-home and community-based care.
The swelling population of seniors will far outpace growth in other age groups. That acceleration — and the slower growth in other age groups — could leave many older Americans with less family to rely on for help in their later years. Meanwhile, federal officials estimate that more than half of people turning 65 will need long-term care services at some point. That care is expensive and can be hard to find.
Spending for paid long-term care already runs about $409 billion a year. Yet that staggering number doesn't begin to reflect the real cost. Experts estimate that 1 in 6 Americans provide billions of dollars' worth of unpaid care to a relative or friend age 50 or older in their home.
As the country weighs Biden's plan, here's a quick look at how long-term care works currently and what might lie ahead. Read the KHN coverage here.
Studies have found that homes owned by for-profit entities racked up more deficiencies and had lower staffing levels, compared with nonprofit facilities.
This article was published on Friday, May 28, 2021 in Kaiser Health News.
The pandemic has highlighted poor care in America's nursing homes, where nearly 175,000 people have died of COVID-19 — a third of all deaths from the disease nationwide.
Even before the pandemic, patient advocates pointed to dangerous conditions in U.S. nursing homes, including staffing shortages and infection control failures. Many nursing homes didn't provide quality care, they charged.
Studies have found that homes owned by for-profit entities racked up more deficiencies and had lower staffing levels, compared with nonprofit facilities. And as the number of for-profit nursing home chains has increased, industry watchdogs and patient advocates say, states aren't doing enough to vet nursing home owners.
California is home to about 1,200 licensed nursing homes. Those facilities care for 100,000 nursing home patients — the biggest nursing home population of any state. For those fragile and vulnerable residents, the situation is fraught: A KPCC investigation found that under state regulations nursing home operators can continue running facilities even after they've been denied a state license.
Cynthia Carrillo learned about this obscure regulatory loophole after the tragic death of older brother David Carrillo, who caught COVID-19 while living in a Southern California nursing home. Cynthia, 58, lives in Rancho Cucamonga, California.
David had Down syndrome and until late 2019 lived with Cynthia and her family. On Christmas Day 2019, Cynthia noticed David wasn't acting like himself.
"He was kind of yelling, screaming. And we're like, OK, something's wrong," Cynthia recalled. She said David was afraid to walk down the stairs in their house. Fearful that her brother was having a medical emergency, she took him to a nearby hospital. There, she said, a doctor told her he was developing dementia.
After being discharged, David landed in Villa Mesa Care Center, a nursing home. It was supposed to be a temporary placement while Cynthia looked for a single-story home without stairs, so the family could bring David back to live with them. "It was very difficult to leave him and go home. So, our goal was to be able to get him out as quick as we could," she said.
Cynthia visited every day, but she said she watched his condition deteriorate. She said that before arriving at Villa Mesa, David walked regularly but, afterward, she noticed he was frequently in a wheelchair and wasn't moving around much. In a lawsuit she has since filed against the nursing home, Cynthia claimed that staff members admitted to giving him a psychotropic drug she didn't authorize, which made him drowsy.
By March 2020, Cynthia had decided to place David in a group home — another temporary fix while she continued her house search. Then the pandemic took hold. David remained at Villa Mesa. When Cynthia went to see him on March 30, she was allowed to visit only through a window. She said there was a sign on the door saying no one should enter without a mask, and yet staff members in the room weren't wearing masks.
"It was very hard for us to see that and to see the staff walking around like nothing was going on, you know, regarding the pandemic," Cynthia said.
Ten days later, she was awoken after midnight by a phone call. It was the hospital across the street from the nursing home. David was in respiratory distress and needed to be intubated. The doctor told her he was coherent, but Cynthia couldn't visit her brother. "I couldn't be there with him, to even let him know everything would be OK," she recalled.
She still cries at the memory of that night. "He was probably wondering where I was."
David Carrillo died of COVID a week later, on April 17, 2020. He was 65.
Since the pandemic began, at least 23 residents at Villa Mesa, a 99-bed facility, have died of the virus, according to federal data.
Cynthia still can't drive by the building without getting upset. "There's just too much," she said. "I get angry. I get frustrated."
A Troubled Chain Seeks to Grow
According to state records reviewed by KPCC, Villa Mesa Care Center is connected to a business called ReNew Health. Across California, KPCC found at least 26 facilities connected to ReNew and ReNew's owner, Crystal Solorzano — they stretch from Orange County to the agricultural Central Valley, and as far north as the San Francisco Bay Area. Solorzano owns, or is applying to own, the majority of them; at five of the nursing homes, including Villa Mesa, ReNew has been involved in management or administration.
In April 2020, the California Department of Public Health denied Solorzano licenses for nine nursing homes she had applied to take over.
Villa Mesa was not one of the nine homes. But Cynthia Carrillo said it's still troubling.
"I think [the state] should be able to close it, close them down completely," she said.
According to California regulations, Solorzano's businesses can still operate the nine facilities despite the license denials.
"The approval process, the licensure process is a farce," said Tony Chicotel, an attorney with California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform. He explained that nursing home owners can take over existing facilities without first getting a license from the state, as long as they submit a license application. Those applications can take years to be processed by state authorities.
"It's a really bizarre, completely exploited process," Chicotel said.
At one facility, a patient with schizophrenia was inappropriately discharged and then went missing for two weeks, before being found unconscious in a park, underneath his wheelchair, according to the state. At another, a nursing assistant was charged with raping a 52-year-old woman who had mental health conditions.
The latter incident was classified as a case of "Immediate Jeopardy," the federal government's term for a situation so dire that regulators determine it "caused, or is likely to cause, serious injury, harm, impairment, or death to a resident."
The facilities connected to ReNew and Solorzano provide care for 1 in 50 of the state's nursing home residents, but they are responsible for nearly 1 in 10 Immediate Jeopardies in California since 2019, according to KPCC's analysis. Immediate Jeopardies are the most severe deficiency a nursing home can be cited for by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
In addition to considering quality of care, regulators who review change-of-ownership applications also determine whether an "applicant is of reputable and responsible character." They found Solorzano lacking. According to the denial letters, the department's review "revealed that in or around July 2008, you submitted fraudulent documents to obtain your nursing home administrator license," specifically a fraudulent college transcript from Touro College.
Staffers at both Touro College and Touro University confirmed that Solorzano had not received a degree from their institutions.
California's Licensing Process
The situation calls into question the state's ability to ensure nursing home operators provide quality care.
"California has, in a sense, rolled out the red carpet for bad providers," attorney Chicotel argued. "You can get in the building, you can be a squatter, and they can't get you out."
In a statement, a ReNew spokesperson wrote that "Ms. Solorzano is fully qualified to own and operate nursing homes, and in fact has specialized in acquiring troubled facilities and turning them around to preserve and maintain critical bed space that would have otherwise been unavailable during the pandemic."
The statement also said that "Solorzano's only focus is maintaining the health and safety of our employees and residents" and added that during the pandemic "facilities continue to follow infection prevention protocols to protect the health and wellbeing of the residents and staff."
The statement did not respond to the violations mentioned in the state's denial letter or the college transcript that CDPH said is fraudulent, although KPCC raised both in a letter to Solorzano and ReNew.
It also didn't address a series of Instagram stories Solorzano shared that promoted misinformation about coronavirus vaccines, including one that said in its description "the COVID vaccine should be avoided at all costs."
Nearly 200 people have died of COVID-19 in facilities connected to ReNew, according to federal data.
The beds in facilities like these will be needed as California's population ages. Demand for nursing home beds is expected to soar by 2030. When a nursing home must shut down, the process can be extremely disruptive for vulnerable patients, and finding them new places to live can be difficult.
Here's how the California Department of Public Health explains the licensing process: The agency said new owners can enter management agreements with the previous ones while the new owners' license applications are pending. Most applications are approved.
But when CDPH denies them — as it did with nine of Solorzano's — the aspiring owners can continue running the facilities even after the denial, so long as they appeal.
The appeal process can drag on for years.
Advocates are calling for more transparency when nursing homes switch hands. Currently, nursing home owners can acquire facilities without first telling the state. One fix? Making nursing home owners obtain a license before operating a facility, and giving the public an opportunity to comment on any change-of-ownership applications.
A recently introduced bill in California would do just that: require nursing home owners to get licensed before taking over a facility.
The legislation is authored by California Assembly member Al Muratsuchi, a Democrat from coastal Southern California. "For these bad actors to be able to continue to operate without a license, and with a record of past abuses, is simply not acceptable," Muratsuchi said. "The current system is broken. And we need to fix it."
Mark Reagan, general counsel for the nursing home industry group California Association of Health Facilities, takes a different view. "At the end of the day, I don't think that patient care is being compromised," he said. Just because an application is rejected, Reagan said, doesn't mean the state forfeits its regulatory tools. Reagan argues that the slowness of the ownership-change process creates headaches and uncertainty for owners — even though most applications are approved.
The bill to overhaul the licensing process has been pushed back to 2022.
'States Aren't Doing a Good Job'
Nursing home regulation — and payment — is split between the federal government and states. Almost all nursing homes receive some federal reimbursements, and therefore must meet federal requirements, which are overseen by state inspectors. The federal certification process makes payments to nursing homes possible, but states serve as gatekeepers because they grant the actual licenses needed to own and operate nursing homes. The criteria for licensure vary by state.
Patient advocates and health researchers say the licensing process can have life-or-death implications in all 50 states. One problem involves the consolidation of the industry, and the growth of nursing home chains, which can operate across state lines. That complicates the work of state health departments. So does the complex web of LLCs and other corporate entities that make up the modern nursing home business. The corporate webs make it difficult for patients' families and even regulators to figure out who is responsible.
"The growing sophistication of the nursing home industry has enabled some owners to leverage and direct assets in a manner that maximizes profits without meaningful accountability for nursing home quality," according to a March 2020 report from the Long Term Care Community Coalition.
Richard Mollot, the coalition's executive director, said it's time for CMS, the federal agency that oversees nursing homes, to step in. "There's really no federal involvement here. And there clearly needs to be, because the states aren't doing a good job of handling it," he said.
Mollot wants the federal government to create clear standards for vetting nursing home operators, rather than leaving the states in charge. "Those rules are so important," he said. "Literally, residents' lives depend upon it."
Additional oversight is especially needed as new investors move into the nursing home industry, said University of California-San Francisco professor emeritus Charlene Harrington. "Many of the owners are private equity companies, they're real estate companies. They have no expertise in nursing homes," she said.
A 2021 study found that mortality increased in nursing homes after private equity firms took over operations. Harrington has written that CMS does not have accurate or complete data on nursing home ownership, and that federal regulators should increase oversight of nursing home chains, rather than focusing on individual facilities.
Since being denied licenses to take over nine nursing homes in 2020, ReNew Health's Solorzano has applied to take over another facility in California. Her appeals to take over the nine nursing homes are pending, with a hearing set for July. The California Department of Public Health is also seeking to revoke her nursing home administrator license. That hearing has not been set.
At Villa Mesa, where David Carrillo was living before he died of COVID, ReNew Health continued to provide services. David's grieving sister finds that hard to take.
"They don't deserve to manage. Not at all," Cynthia Carrillo said.
The facility received two Immediate Jeopardy violations in October 2020.
Carrillo filed her wrongful death lawsuit against the nursing facility in December 2020. The case is pending.
This story is from a partnership that includes KPCC, NPR and KHN.