In a ruling the American Medical Association is hailing as a win for physicians around the nation, the Florida Supreme Court has struck down as unconstitutional a narrowly drawn state statute that had allowed the board of a private, for-profit hospital operating in St. Lucie County to supercede medical staff bylaws.
In Lawnwood Medical Center v. Randall Seeger, MD (as president of the Lawnwood medical staff), the Sunshine State's highest court agreed with a trial court and an appeals court that the so-called St. Lucie County Hospital Governance Law violated the Florida Constitution because it "granted privilege to a private corporation."
Included in the ruling is an affirmation by the high court that medical staff bylaws are a contract between physicians and the hospital that cannot be unilaterally changed. The court noted that the Hospital Governance Law had given the board of directors at the 331-bed Lawnwood "almost absolute power in running the affairs of the hospital, essentially without meaningful regard for the recommendations or actions of the medical staff."
Cecil Wilson, MD, an internist from Winter Park, FL, and an AMA board member, says the ruling sets a favorable precedent for physicians. "If this law in Florida had been allowed to stand, it would have encouraged other hospitals around the country to do similar things," Wilson says. "We believe that having the Florida Supreme Court rule on the sanctity of hospital staff bylaws, while not binding on other states, will be a precedent that other states can look at."
"These bylaws are a contract between the medical staff and the hospital. They lay out responsibilities, duties, and obligations. And, like with any contract, one party is not free to unilaterally change the contract," Wilson says.
The Florida law applies only to the two private hospitals in St. Lucie County, which is located on Florida's east coast, about 100 miles north of Miami. Both hospitals are owned by HCA. HCA's headquarters in Nashville referred questions about the ruling to Lawnwood, which did not return several telephone calls.
Lawnwood successfully pushed the Hospital Governance Law through the Florida Legislature in 2003 after years of fighting with staff physicians on points ranging from credentialing physicians to quality-of-care issues. The issue came to a head in 1999 when Lawnwood removed physicians from its Medical Executive Committee after they declined to recommend disciplinary actions against two staff pathologists that the hospital claimed threatened patient safety.
Wilson says Lawnwood's decision to unilaterally impose its will on the medical staff was "potentially dangerous because it negates the value of the expertise physicians bring to that equation."
"It is up to the hospital board and the medical staff to work together and not have either side making unilateral decisions that don't take into account the input and expertise of the other side," he says. "The happy medium is people working together and both sides not making unilateral decisions."
John Commins is the human resources and community and rural hospitals editor withHealthLeaders Media. He can be reached at jcommins@healthleadersmedia.com.
Note: You can sign up to receive HealthLeaders Media HR, a free weekly e-newsletter that provides up-to-date information on effective HR strategies, recruitment and compensation, physician staffing, and ongoing organizational development.
The National Coalition for Quality Colorectal Cancer Screening and Care has named Randall H.H. Madry, as its new executive director. Most recently, Madry has worked as the deputy commissioner for the North Carolina Department of Insurance, responsible for the regulation of HMOs, PPOs, and third-party administration companies.
HealthMarkets, Inc., the health insurance company that writes policies for the self-insured, individuals and small businesses, has named Tim Roach chief marketing officer. Additionally, Lucinda Lewis has been hired as senior vice president and chief actuary. HealthMarkets does business through its subsidiaries, The MEGA Life and Health Insurance Company, Mid-West National Life Insurance Company of Tennessee and The Chesapeake Life Insurance Company.
WellCare Health Plans, Inc., has hired Rex M. Adams as COO. In this newly created position, Adams will report directly to the president and CEO and have responsibility for the company's operations, including claims payment, customer service and information systems. Before joining WellCare, Adams served as the president and COO of AT&T East, a division of AT&T Inc.
George Hamilton has been promoted to chief administrative officer at Aurora Sinai Medical Center, located in downtown Milwaukee. Hamilton has been at Aurora Sinai since 2000, and most recently served as vice president of operations, and as vice president of academic affairs at Aurora Health Care.
Congressional Democrats have scrapped plans for another vote on expansion of the Children's Health Insurance Program, after concluding that President Bush would not sign their legislation and that they could not override his likely veto. Bush vetoed two earlier versions of the legislation, which he denounced as a dangerous step toward "government-run healthcare for every American." The fight over CHIP prefigures a larger legislative debate over the future of healthcare and the role of government in providing it.
A University of Chicago Medical Center strategy to steer poor and uninsured patients with less serious injuries to other facilities to focus on treating the most challenging cases is attracting growing criticism. In the last three years, the medical center has expanded an effort to educate the uninsured on how to get proper medical care without showing up in its expensive ER. But despite its successes, the initiative has prompted questions from a wide array of skeptics.
Young surgeons at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center have regularly worked more hours than allowed by national safety limits, according to an oversight organization and hospital officials. The group that oversees training of new doctors cited Beth Israel Deaconess for hours violations in a letter in January. The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education said that the hospital would jeopardize its accreditation as a surgery training program if it does not correct the problems by September 9, when council staff plan to review the hospital again.
California's budget impasse is threatening to force the shutdown of many healthcare services across the state if a deal is not struck soon. Without a budget, hospitals, clinics, and homes for disabled residents that rely on state funds to operate will have lost as much as $5.4 billion in state funds by the end of September. State payments for most of them ended in July, and many service providers said they've already received loans, maxed out their credit cards, and even poured in personal funds to keep their centers open.
At free clinics in the Charlotte, NC, area, the demand for healthcare keeps growing as the economy continues to sour and people lose jobs and health insurance. In North Carolina, three out of four uninsured people are from working families, according to the North Carolina Institute of Medicine. Most of these uninsured work in low-wage or part-time jobs.
